Ishanu Chattopadhyay

Assistant Professor of

Data Science / AI / Informatics

Data, ethics, and biases of predictive policing with emerging AI

Rotaru, V., Huang, Y., Li, T. et al. 

Event-level prediction of urban crime reveals a signature of enforcement bias in US cities. Nature Human Behavior 6, 1056–1068 (2022).

https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-022-01372-0

Data, ethics, and biases of predictive policing with emerging AI

Rotaru, V., Huang, Y., Li, T. et al. 

Event-level prediction of urban crime reveals a signature of enforcement bias in US cities. Nature Human Behavior 6, 1056–1068 (2022).

https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-022-01372-0

"You're a real sack of orwellian $xxt. I hope the jackbooted thugs to which you're providing this crime forecast AI never turn it on anyone you hold dear. You're, quite simply, a vile, oppression enabling worm."

The Problem of Free Will

Predictive Policing

Broad patterns are easily predictable

  • Predictions cannot be self-fulfilling prophecies
  • Transparency
  • Account for interactions between crime, social factors and enforcement

Ethically Acceptable Predictive Algorithm For  Enforcement?

The Prediction Problem:

  • Predicting crime sufficiently ahead of time to be actionable
  • Prediction precise enough in time and space to be actionable
  • Use ONLY data that is realistically and cheaply available

1 Week in advance

Within ~2 city blocks

ONLY Past eventlog as input

  • Simulate impact of different policy choices
  • Reveal policy biases

A good predictive model gives us the following fro free:

Predict Hotspots?

Predpol

2 weeks, Chicago, 2017

property crime

violent crime

complex urban topology

Some historical patterns are predictive

Data: Event Log

ID,Case Number,Date,Block,IUCR,Primary Type,Description,Location Description,Arrest,Domestic,Beat,District,Ward,Community Area,FBI Code,X Coordinate,Y Coordinate,Year,Updated On,Latitude,Longitude,Location\\
8316800,HT550945,08/11/2011 11:00:00 AM,086XX S MARQUETTE AVE,1120,DECEPTIVE PRACTICE,FORGERY,RESIDENCE,false,false,0423,004,7,46,10,1195654,1848294,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.738615478,-87.558741896\\
8316805,HT550781,10/20/2011 05:00:00 AM,056XX S ABERDEEN ST,0890,THEFT,FROM BUILDING,RESIDENCE,false,false,0712,007,16,68,06,1169943,1867457,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.791797599,-87.652385205\\
8316806,HT550706,10/20/2011 05:45:00 AM,079XX S LOOMIS BLVD,031A,ROBBERY,ARMED: HANDGUN,STREET,false,false,0612,006,21,71,03,1168370,1852331,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.750323974,-87.658588247\\
8316811,HT539324,10/12/2011 12:23:52 PM,003XX E 75TH ST,2027,NARCOTICS,POSS: CRACK,SMALL RETAIL STORE,true,false,0323,003,6,69,18,1179641,1855355,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.758372192,-87.61719416\\
8316822,HT551031,10/19/2011 02:00:00 AM,071XX W DICKENS AVE,0910,MOTOR VEHICLE THEFT,AUTOMOBILE,SIDEWALK,false,false,2512,025,36,25,07,1127877,1913161,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.918027518,-87.805606689\\
8316824,HT551032,10/20/2011 12:00:00 AM,034XX N NATCHEZ AVE,2825,OTHER OFFENSE,HARASSMENT BY TELEPHONE,RESIDENCE,false,false,1632,016,36,17,26,1132429,1922272,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.94295109,-87.788669409\\
8316825,HT549690,10/19/2011 12:51:00 PM,079XX S ADA ST,2820,OTHER OFFENSE,TELEPHONE THREAT,APARTMENT,false,false,0612,006,21,71,26,1168711,1852015,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.749449482,-87.657347764\\
8316826,HT549865,10/19/2011 06:00:00 AM,011XX N LEAMINGTON AVE,0810,THEFT,OVER \$500,RESIDENTIAL YARD (FRONT/BACK),false,false,1531,015,37,25,06,1141821,1907155,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.9012995,-87.754523767\\
8316827,HT550963,09/01/2011 04:00:00 PM,079XX S LOOMIS BLVD,0610,BURGLARY,FORCIBLE ENTRY,RESIDENCE-GARAGE,false,false,0612,006,21,71,05,1168380,1851969,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.749330381,-87.658562005\\
8316838,HT548010,10/17/2011 03:20:00 PM,055XX N KEDZIE AVE,0820,THEFT,\$500 AND UNDER,"SCHOOL, PUBLIC, GROUNDS",true,false,1712,017,40,13,06,1154047,1936545,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.981712678,-87.708829703\\
8316839,HT551049,10/20/2011 08:50:00 AM,102XX S AVENUE N,0430,BATTERY,AGGRAVATED: OTHER DANG WEAPON,STREET,false,false,0432,004,10,52,04B,1201166,1837763,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.709579698,-87.538903651\\
8316871,HT549680,10/19/2011 01:03:00 PM,044XX N BROADWAY,0460,BATTERY,SIMPLE,DEPARTMENT STORE,false,false,2313,019,46,3,08B,1168460,1929880,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.963123126,-87.65601675\\
8316872,HT551071,10/19/2011 03:10:00 PM,053XX S CALUMET AVE,0810,THEFT,OVER \$500,RESIDENCE,false,false,0234,002,3,40,06,1179390,1869685,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.797700881,-87.617676981\\
8316873,HT551063,10/20/2011 11:10:00 AM,003XX E 47TH ST,1811,NARCOTICS,POSS: CANNABIS 30GMS OR LESS,SIDEWALK,true,false,0222,002,3,38,18,1178980,1873925,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.809345175,-87.619051287\\
8316874,HT550901,10/20/2011 09:11:00 AM,033XX W OGDEN AVE,2022,NARCOTICS,POSS: COCAINE,POLICE FACILITY/VEH PARKING LOT,true,false,1024,010,24,29,18,1154489,1891024,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.856790413,-87.708424071\\
8316875,HT549739,10/19/2011 01:30:00 PM,002XX E GARFIELD BLVD,0820,THEFT,\$500 AND UNDER,CTA BUS,false,false,0232,002,3,40,06,1178645,1868596,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.794729551,-87.620442108\\
8316880,HT549802,10/19/2011 12:00:00 PM,011XX W WILSON AVE,0460,BATTERY,SIMPLE,COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY GROUNDS,false,false,2311,019,46,3,08B,1167612,1930696,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.96538061,-87.659110921\\
8316881,HT431449,08/04/2011 11:00:00 AM,027XX W CHICAGO AVE,0820,THEFT,\$500 AND UNDER,STREET,false,false,1313,012,26,24,06,1157782,1905211,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.895654523,-87.69595021\\
8316882,HT549162,10/19/2011 06:42:00 AM,105XX S WESTERN AVE,0610,BURGLARY,FORCIBLE ENTRY,TAVERN/LIQUOR STORE,false,false,2211,022,19,72,05,1162255,1834721,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.702128701,-87.681485145\\
8316884,HT544972,10/16/2011 04:30:00 AM,103XX S HALSTED ST,1310,CRIMINAL DAMAGE,TO PROPERTY,SMALL RETAIL STORE,false,false,2232,022,34,73,14,1172807,1836192,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.705939683,-87.642803521\\
8316886,HT549777,10/19/2011 02:10:00 PM,014XX W PRATT BLVD,0850,THEFT,ATTEMPT THEFT,SMALL RETAIL STORE,false,false,2431,024,49,1,06,1165565,1945281,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,42.005446228,-87.666219555\\
8316887,HT551046,10/20/2011 11:10:00 AM,050XX N WINTHROP AVE,2820,OTHER OFFENSE,TELEPHONE THREAT,RESIDENCE,false,false,2033,020,48,3,26,1167955,1933907,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.974184283,-87.657756697\\
8316889,HT550997,10/20/2011 09:10:00 AM,041XX N DICKINSON AVE,1121,DECEPTIVE PRACTICE,COUNTERFEITING DOCUMENT,STREET,true,false,1624,016,45,15,10,1142513,1926900,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.955468935,-87.751489799\\
8316890,HT532649,10/07/2011 11:46:00 PM,062XX S VERNON AVE,2092,NARCOTICS,SOLICIT NARCOTICS ON PUBLICWAY,SIDEWALK,true,false,0313,003,20,42,26,1180324,1863694,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.781239632,-87.614435596\\
8316893,HT551023,10/20/2011 02:00:00 AM,081XX S STEWART AVE,0810,THEFT,OVER \$500,STREET,false,false,0622,006,21,44,06,1175042,1850896,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.746239973,-87.634181801\\
8316894,HT550772,10/20/2011 07:10:00 AM,048XX N TALMAN AVE,1320,CRIMINAL DAMAGE,TO VEHICLE,STREET,false,false,2031,020,40,4,14,1157831,1931974,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.969093078,-87.695038453\\
8316898,HT551055,10/16/2011 09:00:00 AM,018XX S LAFLIN ST,1365,CRIMINAL TRESPASS,TO RESIDENCE,APARTMENT,false,false,1222,012,25,31,26,1166665,1891065,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.856651049,-87.663730374\\
8316899,HT550695,10/20/2011 05:30:00 AM,122XX S HALSTED ST,1310,CRIMINAL DAMAGE,TO PROPERTY,RESIDENCE PORCH/HALLWAY,false,false,0524,005,34,53,14,1173210,1823636,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.671475169,-87.641696924\\
8316901,HT549052,10/19/2011 12:01:00 AM,064XX S DR MARTIN LUTHER KING JR DR,1811,NARCOTICS,POSS: CANNABIS 30GMS OR LESS,STREET,true,false,0312,003,20,42,18,1180027,1862432,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.777783389,-87.615563072\\
8316902,HT550988,10/20/2011 10:25:00 AM,066XX S KENNETH AVE,0486,BATTERY,DOMESTIC BATTERY SIMPLE,RESIDENCE,false,false,0833,008,13,65,08B,1147854,1860166,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.772241474,-87.733568892\\
8316909,HT550957,10/20/2011 04:45:00 AM,051XX S MONITOR AVE,2825,OTHER OFFENSE,HARASSMENT BY TELEPHONE,RESIDENCE,false,true,0811,008,23,56,26,1138234,1869952,2011,02/04/2016 06:33:39 AM,41.79927468,-87.768598031\\

 

  • Time stamp
  • Geographical Location
  • Nature of infraction
  • Arrests Made

The Underlying Math

  • Predict the spatio-temporal event risk
  • NOT individual people
  • CANNOT be used for individual "pre-arrests"
  • No manual selection of factors
  • No "lists"
  • Uses only de-identified data
  • Can use the models to "audit" the state
  • Identify and reveal enforcement biases
  • Democratization of AI

93% accuracy

87% AUC

~70% specificity at ~80% sensitivity

Chicago Predictive Performance

10 actual crimes:

11 predicted:

8 correct:

2 missed:

3 false alarms

1 Week in advance

Within ~2 city blocks

ONLY Past eventlog as input

Triangles: actual events

 

heatmap: predicted risk 3 days ahead

 Jan 1 2016 - April 1 2019

Philadelphia

100 crimes

Raise 103 flags

90 correct flags

13 false positives

10 missed

Could we have predicted this?

 

Double homicide

Jan 7 2019

Triple homicide incident

Jan 7 2019

https://www.inquirer.com/crime/kensington-triple-shooting-homicide-philadelphia-police-20190107.html

Triangles: actual events

 

heatmap: predicted risk 3 days ahead

Zip code 19132

in Philadelphia

fp       1.840708
tp      21.530973
fn       2.946903
sens     0.878993
ppv      0.909565
fp      0.106195
tp      3.982301
fn      0.522124
sens    0.881521
ppv     0.960446

property

violent

Property:

Other_Larceny-Larceny_from_MV-Auto_Theft-Residential_Burglary-Robbery-Commercial_Burglary    

Violent:

Aggravated_Assault-Rape_&_Attempted-Homicide                                                 
Property:

Other_Larceny-Larceny_from_MV-Auto_Theft-Residential_Burglary-Robbery-Commercial_Burglary    

Violent:

Aggravated_Assault-Rape_&_Attempted-Homicide

Mean AUC

Property crime: 81%

Violent crime:    84%

Spatial tiles:

0.0028 deg latitude, 0.0019 deg longitude

0.2 miles across

(100 x 300 yds)

Time-period:

Training:                      Jan 1 2021 - March 31 2022

Out-of-sample test:  Apr 1 2022 - July 22 2022

Digital Twin

Not just a predictor

Signature of enforcement

inequity

Rotaru, Victor, Yi Huang, Timmy Li, James Evans, and Ishanu Chattopadhyay. "Event-level prediction of urban crime reveals a signature of enforcement bias in US cities." Nature human behaviour 6, no. 8 (2022): 1056-1068.

The Brave New World

Everything is predictable, the only question is by how much?

VeRITaAS

Can A Generative AI Tell if you Are Lying?

Vetting Response Integrity from
cross-Talk in Adversarial
Surveys

Hidden structure of cross-talk between responses to interview items

PTSD diagnostic interview

Number of possible responses

Minimum Performance (n=624)

Average Time: 3.5 min

No. of questions: 20

AUC > 0.95

PPV > 0.86

NPV > 0.92

At least 83.3% sensitivity at 94% specificity

Minimum AUC = \(0.95 \pm 0.005\)

Cannot be coached, or memorized

Datasets for training & validation

1. VA (n=294)

2. Prolific (n=300)

3. Psychiatrists (n=30)

10^{25}

Beat the test!

paraknowledge.ai/veritas

200 participants in

US

100 participants in

UK

30 forensic psychiatrists

10

6

1

Can-You-Fake-PTSD Challenge Results

successful attempts

Future

Vision

Transform bio-surveillance

Democratize AI unleashing its power for social good

Transform early diagnosis

Transform modeling of complex systems

Acknowledgements