How has the long history of colonialism affected the lives and music cultures of Pacific Islanders and Native Hawaiians?
How have Native Hawaiians and other Pacific Islanders resisted and continue to resist colonialism?
1898 Rosina Kalanikauwekiulani Ayers's "Hawaiian Coat-of-Arms" Quilt, by unknown artist. National Museum of American History.
30+ minutes
Kafa, unknown artist. AUVDIS-UNESCO.
In the early 19th century, French explorer Jules-Sébastien-César Dumont d'Urville divided the region into three parts: Melanesia, Micronesia and Polynesia.
There are tens of thousands of Pacific Islands. Today, this region includes 15 countries and territories/states of many different countries.
The Three Cultural Regions of the Pacific, by CartoGIS Services, CC-BY-SA-4.0, via Australian University College of Asia and the Pacific.
D'Urville's tripartite division was based on his observations of cultural, linguistic and phenotypic differences. It has based partly on out-of-date racial theories, and many see his boundaries as arbitrary.
Nonetheless, because scholars continue to disagree about the history of migration to the Pacific Islands, there is no widely accepted alternative. D'Urville's division is still used to organize museum collections and to influence the scope of scholars' research.
Jules-Sébastien-César Dumont d'Urville, by Jérôme Cartellier. {{PD-US-expired}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
How can we discover information about the original settlers of an island?
As a class or in small groups, research and discuss what knowledge each methodology/source can generate, and what it can't.
Is knowledge about the original settlement of Pacific Islands useful?
What ethical issues are raised when we study the original settlement of any Pacific Island?
The Indigenous languages of most Pacific Islands belong to the Oceanic branch of Austronesian languages. These include Fijian, Samoan, Tahitian, Chamorro (Mariana Islands, including Guam), Tongan, and Hawaiian.
Chronological Dispersal of Austronesian People across the Pacific, by Obsidian Soul, CC-BY-4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The Indigenous languages of Papua New Guinea and nearby islands often belong to the loose category of Papuan languages.
What does information about language groups tell you about the Pacific Islands?
Papua New Guinea
Australia
Indonesia
The recording we will listen to next is from the island of Futuna in southern Vanuatu, which is located over 1,000 miles to the east of northern Australia. (see arrow).
Listen to an excerpt:
When do you think it was recorded?
What do you think was the purpose of this music?
"Kafa" used to be a feature of all-night rituals. It involved people seated on both sides of a long piece of bamboo. They would hit the bamboo to establish a beat, and chant over the beat.
This performance was recorded in 1990.
Listen again with this context in mind.
From 1906 to 1980, France and Britain ruled Vanuatu through the "Anglo-French Condominium." Christian missionaries and authorities, often supported by colonial officials, discouraged traditional dances and disrupted these traditions. After Vanuatu achieved independence in 1980, the government has supported traditional culture. Nonetheless, you can hear Western influences in traditional music and dance practices today.
Cultural Dancers Welcome Participants of KOA MOANA and Guests with a Traditional Dance, by Grady Fontana. Public Domain {{PD-US}}, via Picryl.
Listen again.
Do you hear any Western influences in this performance?
The prevalence of Austronesian languages reveals a level of cultural kinship across many of the Pacific Islands. Nonetheless, there is significant diversity, partly because different islands had contrasting experiences with colonialism.
The remainder of this component focuses on one set of islands: Hawaiʻi.
Hawai'i is located in the far northeast of Polynesia. Created by volcanic activities, it consists of eight major islands. From west to east, they are: Niʻihau, Kauaʻi, Oʻahu, Molokaʻi, Lanaʻi, Kahoʻolawe, Maui, and the Big Island of Hawaiʻi. There are also over 100 smaller islands.
The earliest Hawaiians arrived from islands in the South Pacific. Estimates of when settlement began vary widely, from 400CE to 1100CE.
Given their origins, Hawaiian languages and cultures are closely related to those of the Marquesas and Society Islands (including Tahiti).
Indigenous religious practices are similar to those found on many other islands in Polynesia.
It is polytheist, involving the worship of many deities and spirits. Each family also has at least one guardian spirit.
Pu'ukoholā Heiau, unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US}}, National Park Service.
Kapu was a code of conduct that stems from Indigenous Hawaiian religion, and it covered relationships between humans and deities, different groups of people (including gender roles and social classes), and people and nature.
The Mahiole, or Feathered Helmet, of Chief Kalani‘ōpu‘u, Given to James Cook in 1779, CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0, courtesy of the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.
Members of nobility and kahunas (priests or wise men) were in charge of interpreting the kapu.
Before the 19th Century, hula dances--which involved chanting as well as percussion instruments including drums, gourds filled with seeds and bamboo rattles--served to reinforce the kapu. They honored deities, and praised chiefs and their ancestors.
Five of Ioane Ukeke's Hula Dancers, by A.A. Montano. Public Domain {{PD-US}}, via Picryl.
Hula is one of the most recognized art forms from Hawai'i.
Although Spanish ships might have landed in Hawai'i in the mid-16th century, the consequential contact occurred when an expedition led by James Cook arrived in 1778.
Cook was killed in Hawaiʻi in 1779. However, his expedition sparked the regular arrival of trading and whaling ships.
Top: Death of Cook, by James Cleveley. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}. Bottom: The Death of Captain James Cook at Kealakekua Bay, Hawaii, unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
One key result of these trading ships is that Kamehameha, the ruler of the Big Island, was able to secure superior weaponry. This gave him the military advantage he needed to conquer Maui, Molokaʻi, Lānaʻi, and eventually Oʻahu.
Kamehameha, King of the Sandwich Islands, by Louis Choris. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
In 1795, he founded and became the first ruler of the Kingdom of Hawaiʻi.
Beginning in the 1820s, Christian missionaries began arriving in Hawaiʻi, sparking many social changes.
Hawaiʻi became a chief producer of sugar in the mid-/late-19th century. Among the key reasons are:
Daniel Dole, unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
Since their arrival, many Christian missionaries have discouraged and--sometimes with the help of political elites--attempted to ban or heavily tax the teaching and performance of hula.
They were ultimately unsuccessful in eliminating hula, but the tradition had to be passed down in somewhat clandestine ways for many decades.
Hula Dancers, ca. 1856, unknown artist. Public Domain, {{PD-US-expired}} via Picryl.
American missionaries and sugar plantations brought immigrants from many countries. They included:
Chinese Contract Laborers on a Sugar Plantation in 19th Century Hawaii, unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US-Expired}}, via Picryl.
As the 19th century proceeded, plantation owners and their allies demanded more power. They were willing to threaten and use force to gain it.
Liliuokalani, c. 1891, by James J. Williams. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
In 1893, they overthrew the Kingdom of Hawaiʻi. President Grover Cleveland recognized the illegality of the overthrow, but failed to act.
In 1897, the new U.S. President--William McKinley--signaled his support for the annexation of Hawaiʻi. Congress ratified the annexation in July 1898.
Queen Liliuokalani, the last ruler of the Kingdom of Hawai'i, was also a musician and songwriter. Her most famous composition was "Aloha Oe": A song about saying goodbye to someone you love.
Have you heard this song before? Where?
Does this music sound "Hawaiian" to you? Why?
To explore the complexities of identifying an authentic "Hawaiian sound," visit Component 2.
Listen to an excerpt from this instrumental version of the song.
Liliuokalani, by Menzies Dickson. National Portrait Gallery.
With the abolition of the kapu system in 1819, increasing foreign incursions due to the establishment of sugar plantations, and the US annexation in 1898, hula needed a new purpose.
Hula Girls, 1920, by Harry Shipler. Public Domain {{PD -US-expired}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
Since the late 19th century, hula--now performed with guitars, ukuleles and other Western instruments--has become a centerpiece in Hawaiian tourism.
Native Hawaiians have resisted U.S. colonialism even before the annexation.
Petition Against the Annexation of Hawaii. Public Domain {{PD-US}}, National Archives.
In an attempt to maintain their nation and to preserve their cultural identity, more than 21,000 Native Hawaiians (over half the population) signed a petition against annexation in 1897. This petition temporarily defeated annexation efforts, but legislation was passed a year later.
In the 1960s, a new movement to revive Native Hawaiian culture emerged.
Over the past half century, there have been great interest in reviving Hawaiian language, and traditional Hawaiian arts and crafts as they existed before the overthrow in 1893.
Kapa or Tapa Cloth, Hawaii, Collected before 1890, unknown maker. CC0 1.0, Peabody Museum, Harvard University.
Small groups of dancers kept more traditional hula practices alive for over a century. Since the Hawaiian Renaissance in the 1970s, interest in traditional hula (or hula kahiko) has increased dramatically.
Excerpt of Hula Kahiko Performance at the Hawai'i Celebration 2017, uploaded by Smithsonian NMAI.
Does this match your expectation of what "hula" looks and sounds like? Why or why not?
Many musicians were active in the Hawaiian Renaissance. They promoted the use of slack-key guitars, steel guitars, falsetto singing, and other techniques and sounds that are now often seen as "authentically" Hawaiian.
Olomana, "Mele o Kahoʻolawe", uploaded by 8YASO.
See Component 2 to learn more about the complexities of identifying one “authentic” Hawaiian sound.
25+ minutes
Kini Kapahu and Fellow Hula Dancer at the Midway Plaisance at the World's Columbian Exhibition, Chicago, 1893, by John B. Wilson. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}, via Picryl.
Hawai'i is a settler colonial state. It is a place where the Indigenous population, decimated largely by disease, is ruled by a colonial power, and is significantly outnumbered by migrants from the Americas, Asia and Europe.
Over the past two centuries, significant numbers of Native Hawaiians have also moved off the islands.
Spanish Children from the SS Heliopolis After Arriving in Hawaii, unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
Total State Population: 1.46 million
These statistics show the prevalence of mixed-race identities in Hawai'i.
Nearly as many Native Hawaiians live outside Hawai'i as inside the state.
Most leave to pursue better job and educational opportunities, and to places with lower living costs.
The vast majority of the Native Hawaiian Diaspora live on the continental United States, especially California.
Given the racial diversity in Hawai'i and the fact that nearly half of Native Hawaiians live outside the state, the definition of "Hawaiian music" is highly contested. Some key questions are:
In this component, we will explore these questions through an examination of the slack-key guitar tradition.
For Ledward Kaapana (see video on right), what makes slack-key guitar music Hawaiian?
It is unclear how the guitar arrived in Hawai'i. It might have been brought by:
The guitar was popular in Hawai'i by the mid-19th century.
A slack-key guitar is a standard six-string guitar with reduced tension ("slackened") on one or more strings. The result is lower pitches. The open strings generally create a major chord. It is played "fingerstyle" (i.e., no picks).
Slack-Key Guitar Master Raymond Kane (1925-2008), by Tom Pich. National Endowment for the Arts.
There is no "standard" tuning for slack-key guitar. Traditionally, many players are very secretive about the tuning they use.
The slack-key guitar tradition emerged in the mid-19th century, in the midst of momentous changes in Hawaiian society.
Kamehameha III (reigned 1825-54), unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}, via Wikimedia Commons.
In 1848, a system of private property replaced a system where all lands were controlled by the kings or high chiefs. Shortly afterwards, foreign ownership of land was approved. For most Hawaiians (particularly commoners), these laws were experienced as land dispossession.
The development of private property led to the rise of foreign-owned ranches. To train Hawaiians to raise cattle, some owners imported Mexcian vaqueros (cowboys).
Many people, including numerous slack-key guitarists, believe that vaqueros brought their guitars to ranches. Hawaiian cowboys then localized the musical practices the vaqueros taught, thereby creating the slack-key guitar tradition.
Hawaiian Cowboy "Papale"-Style Hat. National Museum of American History.
Several scholars have pointed out problems with the "accepted" narrative:
Hawaiian Paniolo (Cowboy), ca. 1900-1920, unknown artist. Public Domain {{PD-US-expired}}, via Picryl.
The first known recording of slack-key guitar was made by Gabby Pahinui in 1946. The song is entitled "Hi'ilawe" (first part of video on right).
Overall, we know very little about the first century of the slack-key guitar tradition, as it remained music for private entertainment.
Gabby Pahinui - Hi'ilawe 1947, Luau Hula (1972), uploaded by lilacwine85.
Since the beginning of the Hawaiian Renaissance in the 1960s, slack-key guitar has been seen as a true expression of Native Hawaiian culture.
This was when the vaqueros theory gained traction. Sonny Chillingworth's "Waimea Cowboy" (vaqueros worked on ranches in Waimea) refers to this narrative.
"Waimea Cowboy," Sonny Chillingworth. Mahalo Records.
Scholar Kevin Fellezs argues that, for slack-key guitarists, ideas of the rural and Hawaiian cowboys (paniolos) offer the opportunity for recuperation.
Slack-key guitarists recognize that their tradition is unlike hula, which was established long before European contact. They show that "being Hawaiian" in contemporary society involves "mixing foreign and indigenous elements."
"Wai Okeaniani," Ledward Kaapana. Smithsonian Folkways Recordings.
Having heard three examples of slack-key guitar songs:
Fellezs argues that the key aesthetic for the Hawaiian slack-key guitar tradition is nahenahe: an emphasis on softness, sweetness and melodiousness. Value is placed on achieving an "apparent effortlessness."
Leonard Kwan and Raymond Kane even recorded an instrumental called "Nahenahe."
"Nahenahe," Leonard Kwan and Raymond Kane. Tradewind Records.
Fellezs further argues that--to be accepted into the slack-key 'ohana (Native Hawaiian concept of extended family)--musicians must respect and practice key Native Hawaiian concepts, including:
Hawaii Idyllic Landscape, by Pexels. CC0, via pixabay.com.
It is through the nahenahe aesthetic and the continued practicing of these Native Hawaiian cultural values that the slack-key guitar tradition can serve as a recuperative space under settler colonialism.
30+ minutes
Thirty Meter Telescope Blockade on Mauna Kea by Occupy Hilo. CC-BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr.
Music can serve many political purposes. Some songs are used to support the status quo and those with power.
Text
"Hail to the Chief" was originally a Scottish Gaelic tune. For much of U.S. history, it has served as the personal anthem of the U.S. President. It is designed to praise and enhance the stature of presidents.
"Hail to the Chief" - "The President's Own" United States Marine Band. Uploaded by United States Marine Band.
Some songs are used to protest existing structures as well as those with power.
Text
"We Shall Overcome" was originally a gospel song with lyrics descended from a hymn called "I'll Overcome Some Day." In the 20th century, the song was used in labor movements, and became the unofficial anthem of the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s. In this film (starting at 12:57), Joan Baez leads this song at the 1963 March on Washington.
Political songs can come in all sorts of genres and formats. Some are meant for mass singing at protests and other events, but others are meant for solo performance.
One example is the anti-lynching song "Strange Fruit," which Billie Holiday recorded in 1939.
Billie Holiday - "Strange Fruit" Live 1959 [Reelin' In The Years Archives]. Uploaded by ReelinInTheYears66.
Most of the time, national anthems are used to support the power of the state. However, as Colin Kaepernick and many others have shown, national anthems can also serve as sites for protest.
Listeners have argued about the meaning of Jimi Hendrix's performance of "The Star-Spangled Banner" at Woodstock for 50 years. Is it protest, patriotism, sensationalism, or some combination of the three?
Even before the U.S. officially annexed Hawai'i in 1988, Native Hawaiians have been writing anti-colonial songs.
The most famous of these early songs is "Kaulana Nā Pua." Written by Ellen Keho`ohiwaokalani Wright Prendergast in 1893, the lyrics call annexation a "sin" that involves the "sale of native civil rights." In this video, Hawaiian participants at the Smithsonian Folklife Festival in 2013 sing this song.
Hawaiian Participants Sing "Kaulana Nā Pua". Smithsonian Folklife.
Born in Kamala'ula on the island of Molokai, George Helm (1950-77) understood the potential of music as a political tool. He sang songs about Hawaiian land and history, and was a leader in the fight to get the U.S. Navy to stop using the island of Kahoʻolawe for bombardment training.
"Kamala'ula" was originally written by Emma Kala Dudoit in 1922. Helm sings it as a tribute to his hometown.
"Kalama'ula" performed by George Helm. Uploaded by The Orchard Enterprises.
George Helm continues to be viewed as one of the greatest heroes of the "Aloha ʻĀina" ("Love of the Land") movement.
"Aloha ʻĀina" focused on land struggles, which includes demilitarization, the restoration of native ecology, and the revitalization of ancient practices.
In this video, native Hawaiian filmmaker 'Āina Paikai discussed why he made a Helm biopic entitled "Hawaiian Soul."
Hawaiian Soul: The Making of a Short Film About George Helm. Uploaded by Office of Hawaiian Affairs.
Mauna Kea is a dormant volcano on the big island of Hawai'i. It is also a sacred site for Native Hawaiians.
In the 1960s, the U.S. government decided to build observatories on Mauna Kea. This quickly met opposition from many Native Hawaiians. This opposition strengthened radically after the building of the Thirty Meter Telescope at the top of Mauna Kea was proposed.
This photo shows the blockade line at the thirty meter telescope protest on October 7, 2014.
These protests have led to the creation of several dozen protest songs.
The unofficial anthem of the movement is a 2007 song by Hinaleimoana Wong entitled "Kū Ha’aheo E Ku’u Hawai’i" ("Be Proud of My Hawaiians").
Now that you have studied many political songs (both pro- and anti-establishment), discuss the following questions as a class or in small groups:
For those who want to create a new melody, consider these steps:
For those who prefer using an existing melody:
To what extent can performers and listeners alter the meaning of a political song?
In what ways is writing a political song easy? In what ways is it challenging?
How might your song be a useful political tool?
To what extent is the political nature of a song determined by the song's melodies and lyrics?
© 2022 Smithsonian Institution. Personal, educational, and non-commercial uses allowed; commercial rights reserved. See Smithsonian terms of use for more information.
This project received Federal support from the Asian Pacific American Initiatives Pool, administered by the Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center.
For full bibliography and media credits, see Lesson 4 landing page.
Audio courtesy of
Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
Video courtesy of
Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
National Museum of the American Indian
Office of Hawaiian Affairs
Images courtesy of
National Museum of American History
National Park Service
Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongrewa
National Portrait Gallery
National Archives
National Endowment for the Arts