Sep 4, 2020
I rely heavily on stats, but there’s some nuance to that position. I generally use stat rankings strictly as a threshold criterion. In effect, what this means is that players who rank high stats-wise go on my “prospect radar.” It’s these players that I scrutinize a lot more, try to watch more film (“eye test” them) and generally try to project them as NBA players. Among this group of high-ranking players, there are always “false positives” that I'll try to weed out, ie guys with great stats that probably won’t translate to the NBA for one reason or another. For example, lack of athleticism or size can be a deal-breaker on even the seemingly most productive prospects. On the other hand, if a player is just really unproductive or uninteresting (nothing stands out) stats-wise, they usually just aren’t great NBA prospects. And if such a player does get hyped (often because they entered college as a top recruit), I generally try to push back a bit or play the role of skeptic. There are some players like that every year and certainly in this class. On occasion, there are also likely to be “false negatives,” guys that don’t have great stats but still go on to become good or even great NBA players. Pascal Siakam is a good recent example of a guy who didn’t have an amazing statistical profile and yet has become a star. Then again, it’s possible Toronto had a really good stats model! I've done some "meta" Draft analysis, looking back at previous Drafts, and found
that there are generally around 20-25 guys in each class that make a lasting impact in the NBA and roughly half that amount that stay in the league 10+ years. Therefore, I really subscribe to the "tier system" trying to identify these top guys realizing that most guys in any Draft really won't matter in the long run. My "Draft Philosophy" in a nutshell focuses more on trying to identify the stars and difference makers, rather than the "backup point guards" or "rotation bigs" that litter every Draft. I tend to value offensive skill, basketball IQ, and youth, as I believe there is generally more upside to prospects with these attributes. Size and athleticism at every position is always a positive, that is a given, as is the ability to dribble, pass, and shoot; although, the smaller the player, the more important these skills become. I also value players more that will succeed in a variety of team contexts ("synergy"). You can never have too many good shooters or passers or defenders. Some skills like rebounding are overrated from a value standpoint, and I tend to stay away from bigs who derive most of their value from it. Likewise, players who derive most of their value from inefficient mid-range scoring don't appeal to me. Finally, players that bring "unique" or "outlier" skill sets tend to intrigue me because they can potentially contribute unconventional or novel team-building strategies. It's really all about team building!
*Adapted from my discussion here https://theathletic.com/1690276/2020/03/20/obi-toppin-tyrese-halliburton-and-more-talking-2020-nba-draft-with-evan-zamir/
I ran a bunch of polls on Twitter to gauge sentiment on prospects (the poll for LaMelo Ball is shown in the inset). The chart summarizes the results and orders players by an MVP-like voting system which gives 4 points for the top tier, 3 points for the next tier, and so on. Because Twitter limits polls to 4 options, I couldn't fit all 6 of my tier definitions, but this should be a pretty good approximation of #DraftTwitter sentiment (biased of course by my followers). Total votes in parentheses.
*ESPN rank in parentheses next to player
Mock Draft*
*Based on randomized Lottery order
| Pick | Team | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | CHI | LaMelo Ball |
| 2 | ATL | Anthony Edwards |
| 3 | GSW | Aleksej Pokusevski |
| 4 | WAS | Deni Avdija |
| 5 | CLE | James Wiseman |
| 6 | MIN | Patrick Williams |
| 7 | DET | Devin Vassell |
| 8 | NYK | Killian Hayes |
| 9 | CHO | Onyeka Okongwu |
| 10 | PHO | Kira Lewis |
| 11 | SAS | Josh Green |
| 12 | SAC | Tyrese Haliburton |
| 13 | NOP | Isaac Okoro |
| 14 | POR | Obi Toppin |
| 15 | ORL | Grant Riller |
| 16 | MIN | Tyrell Terry |
| 17 | BOS | Killian Tillie |
| 18 | DAL | Cole Anthony |
| 19 | MIL | Theo Maledon |
| 20 | BKN | Desmond Bane |
| 21 | DEN | Saddiq Bey |
| 22 | PHI | Tyrese Maxey |
| 23 | MIA | Aaron Nesmith |
| 24 | UTA | Leandro Bolmaro |
| 25 | OKC | Reggie Perry |
| 26 | BOS | Zeke Nnaji |
| 27 | NYK | RJ Hampton |
| 28 | TOR | Jahmi'us Ramsey |
| 29 | LAL | Xavier Tillman |
| 30 | BOS | Jaden McDaniels |
| 31 | DAL | Skylar Mays |
| 32 | CHA | Robert Woodard |
| 33 | MIN | CJ Elleby |
| 34 | PHI | Jalen Harris |
| 35 | SAC | Jalen Smith |
| 36 | PHI | Devon Dotson |
| 37 | WAS | Precious Achiuwa |
| 38 | NYK | Tre Jones |
| 39 | NOP | Cassius Winston |
| 40 | MEM | Nico Mannion |
| 41 | SAS | Tyler Bey |
| 42 | NOP | Malik Fitts |
| 43 | SAC | Vernon Carey |
| 44 | POR | Isaiah Stewart |
| 45 | ORL | Malachi Flynn |
| 46 | BOS | Tres Tinkle |
| 47 | CHI | Jordan Nwora |
| 48 | GSW | Ty-Shon Alexander |
| 49 | PHI | Mason Jones |
| 50 | IND | Cassius Stanley |
| 51 | OKC | Nate Hinton |
| 52 | ATL | Elijah Hughes |
| 53 | SAC | Trevelin Queen |
| 54 | GSW | Lamine Diane |
| 55 | BKN | Udoka Azubuike |
| 56 | CHA | Sam Merrill |
| 57 | LAC | Immanuel Quickley |
| 58 | TOR | Daniel Oturu |
| 59 | PHI | Saben Lee |
| 60 | NOP | Mamadi Diakite |
Tier II
Tier III
Tier IV
Tier V
Tier V
Tier VI
MVP/All-NBA 1st or 2nd Team/Supermax
Multiple All-Star Appearances/All-NBA/Max
August 22, 2001
Illawara - NBL
Point Guard
6'7" 180 lbs
6'10" ws ~8'6" sr
Combination of size, ball-handling, IQ, and passing ability makes for a point guard prospect with a high ceiling outcome, even if his shooting is never elite.
August 5, 2001
Freshman - Georgia
Guard
6'5" 225 lbs
6'9" ws 8'4" sr
Star potential clearly in the range of outcomes given his combination of physical tools, skill set, and youth. Floor outcome possible if his motor and IQ stagnate.
Dec 26, 2001
Olympiacos - Greek A2
Power Forward/Center
7' 205 lbs
7'3" ws ~9'2.5" sr
Unicorn outcome in play if he can handle the physicality of the NBA game. Barely old enough to qualify for the Draft, a patient far-sighted team could be greatly rewarded for taking a leap of faith.
High-End Playoff Starter/Team Core/Fringe or 1 time All-Star
Jan 3, 2001
Maccabi Tel Aviv
Wing/Forward
6'8.5" 219 lbs
6'9" ws ~8'6" sr
August 6, 2001
Freshman - Florida State
Small Forward/Power Forward
6'8" 225 lbs
6'11" ws ~8'10" sr
Aug 23, 2000
Sophomore - Florida State
Point Guard/Combo Guard
6'7" 194 lbs
6'9" ws ~8'7" sr
Nov 16, 2000
Freshman - University of Arizona
Wing
6'5.5" 209 lbs
6'10" ws ~8'7" sr
Jan 26, 2001
Freshman - University of Auburn
Guard
6'6" 225 lbs
6'8.5" ws ~8'4.5" sr
July 27, 2001
Ratiopharm Ulm - Bundesliga (Germany)
Point Guard
6'5" 192 lbs
6'8" ws ~8'5" sr
April 6, 2001
Sophomore - University of Alabama
Point Guard
6'3" 165 lbs
6'6.5" ws ~8'3" sr
Mar 31, 2001
Freshman - University of Memphis
Center
7'1" 235 lbs
7'5" ws ~9'5" sr
Dec 11, 2000
Freshman - University of Southern California
Center
6'9" 245 lbs
7'2" ws ~9' sr
Mar 4, 1998
Sophomore - Dayton University
Power Forward/Center
6'9" 220 lbs
6'11" ws ~8'10" sr
Fringe Starter/High-end Role Player/6MOY
Jun 25, 1998
Senior - TCU
Guard/Wing
6'5" 215 lbs
~6'4" ws ~8'4" sr
Aug 18, 1999
Freshman - Duke University
Wing
6'6" 194 lbs
6'6" ws ~8'4" sr
April 9, 1999
Sophomore - Villanova University
Wing/Forward
6'8" 216 lbs
6'11" ws ~8'9" sr
Oct 16, 1999
Sophomore - Vanderbilty University
Wing
6'6" 213 lbs
6'10" ws ~8'7" sr
Feb 29, 2000
Sophomore - Iowa State
Guard/Wing
6'5" 175 lbs
6'7" ws ~8'5" sr
Feb 8, 1997
Senior - College of Charleston
Combo Guard
6'3" 190 lbs
6'5" ws ~8'3" sr
Sept 28, 2000
Freshman - Stanford
Point Guard
6'3" 160 lbs
6'2.5" ws ~8" sr
May 15, 2000
Freshman - University of North Carolina
Point Guard/Combo Guard
6'3" 190 lbs
6'4.5" ws ~8' sr
Jun 12, 2001
ASVEL - EuroLeague
Point Guard
6'5" 174 lbs
~6'9" ws ~8'4.5" sr
Nov 4, 2000
Freshman - University of Kentucky
Combo Guard
6'3" 198 lbs
6'6" ws ~8'3.5" sr
Mar 5, 1998
Senior - Gonzaga University
Forward/Center
6'9.5" 230 lbs
6'8" ws ~8'9.5" sr
Solid Rotation/Journeyman
June 16, 2000
Sophomore - Washington State
Shooting Guard/Small Forward
6'7" 195 lbs
6'7" ws ~8'5.5" sr
Sep 22, 1999
Sophomore - Mississippi State University
Wing/Forward
6'7" 235 lbs
7'1" ws ~8'8" sr
July 4, 1997
Senior - Saint Mary's
Wing/Forward
6'8" 230 lbs
6'11.5" ws ~8'8" sr
Feb 10, 1998
Junior - University of Colorado
Power Forward
6'7" 220 lbs
7' ws ~8'9" sr
Sep 11, 2000
FC Barcelona Lassa - ACB/EuroLeague
Guard/Wing
6'7" 200 lbs
~6'9" ws ~8'7" sr
Feb 7, 2001
New Zealand - NBL
Guard
6'5" 185 lbs
6'7" ws ~8'3" sr
June 9, 2001
Freshman - Texas Tech University
Guard
6'4" 195 lbs
6'6" ws ~8'3.5" sr
Sep 15, 1997
Senior - LSU
Guard/Wing
6'4" 205 lbs
6'6" ws ~8'4" sr
Aug 14, 1998
Junior - Nevada
Guard
6'5" 195 lbs
6'7" ws ~8'4" sr
Aug 2, 1999
Sophomore - University of Kansas
Point Guard
6'1" 185 lbs
6'3" ws ~8' sr
Jan 8, 2000
Sophomore - Duke University
Point Guard
6'3" 185 lbs
6'4" ws ~8' sr
Feb 28, 1998
Senior - Michigan St.
Point Guard
6'1" 185 lbs
6'5" ws ~8'0.5" sr
Mar 14, 2001
Freshman - University of Arizona
Point Guard
6'3" 190 lbs
6'2" ws ~7'10" sr
Mar 21, 2000
Sophomore - Mississippi State
Power Forward/Center
6'9" 250 lbs
7'0.5" ws ~8'10" sr
Jan 9, 2001
Freshman - University of Arizona
Center
6'11" 240 lbs
7'1" ws ~9' sr
Jan 12, 1999
Junior - Michigan State
Power Forward/Center
6'8" 245 lbs
7'1" ws ~8'10" sr
Sep 29, 2000
Freshman - University of Washington
Forward
6'10" 200 lbs
7' ws ~8'11" sr
Mar 16, 2000
Sophomore - University of Maryland
Center
6'10" 220 lbs
7'2" ws ~9' sr
Sep 19, 1999
Freshman - University of Memphis
Forward/Center
6'9" 225 lbs
7'2" ws ~9' sr
Feb 15, 2001
Freshman - Duke
Center
6'10" 270 lbs
7'1" ws ~9'1" sr
May 22, 2001
Freshman - Washington
Center
6'9" 250 lbs
7'4" ws ~9' sr
Two-Way/10-day/SL/GL/Europe
June 2, 1996
Senior - Oregon State
Wing
6'7" 225 lbs
6'11.5" ws ~8'8" sr
Sep 9, 1998
Junior - Louisville
Wing/Forward
6'7" 220 lbs
6'10.5" ws ~8'7" sr
Mar 10, 1998
RS Junior - Syracuse
Wing
6'6" 215 lbs
~6'8" ws ~8'5" sr
Feb 25, 1997
Sophomore - New Mexico St.
Guard
6'6" 190 lbs
6'10" ws ~8'8" sr
Nov 7, 1997
Sophomore - Cal. St. Northridge
Wing
6'7" 205 lbs
~7" ws ~8'9" sr
Aug 11, 1997
RS Junior - SMU
Wing/Forward
6'8" 216 lbs
~6'11" ws ~8'10" sr
Sep 15, 1998
Sophomore - LSU
Wing/Forward
6'6" 230 lbs
6'11" ws 8'10" sr
Jul 9, 1997
Senior - Penn St.
Power Forward
6'8" 225 lbs
~6'9" ws ~8'7" sr
Oct 19, 1997
Senior - Oklahoma
Wing
6'7" 232 lbs
~6'9" ws ~8'7" sr
May 10, 1998
Junior - San Diego St.
Point Guard
6'1" 185 lbs
6'3" ws ~7'10.5" sr
Jul 16, 1998
Junior - Creighton
Shooting Guard
6'4" 195 lbs
6'6" ws ~8'3" sr
July 21, 1998
Sophomore - Arkansas
Guard
6'5" 200 lbs
~6'6" ws ~8'3" sr
Jun 8, 1999
Sophomore - Houston
Guard
6'5" 210 lbs
6'9" ws ~8'5" sr
May 15, 1996
Senior - Utah St.
Guard
6'5" 205 lbs
~6'6" ws ~8'4" sr
Jun 17, 1999
Sophomore - Kentucky
Combo Guard
6'3" 188 lbs
~6'8" ws ~8'3.5" sr
Jun 23, 1999
Junior - Vanderbilt
Point Guard
6'2" 183 lbs
6'8.5" ws ~8'2" sr
Jul 7, 1997
Senior - Seton Hall
Combo Guard
6'2" 195 lbs
~6'7" ws ~8'3" sr
Mar 21, 1997
Senior - Connecticut
Point Guard
6'2" 187 lbs
~6'4" ws ~8'1" sr
Jan 28, 1998
Senior - Oregon
Point Guard
6'2" 202 lbs
6'4" ws ~8'0.5" sr
Mar 3, 1999
Senior - Marquette
Combo Guard
5'11" 180 lbs
~6' ws ~7'10" sr
July 8, 1999
Sophomore - Kentucky
Point Guard
6'3" 198 lbs
6'6" ws ~8'2" sr
Oct 7, 1997
Senior - Maryland
Point Guard
6'0" 180 lbs
~6'2" ws ~8'0" sr
May 26, 1998
Senior - Saint Mary's
Point Guard
6'1" 175 lbs
~6'1" ws ~7'11" sr
Jul 15, 1997
Senior - Northeastern
Combo Guard
6'1" 172 lbs
~6'3" ws ~8' sr
Aug 25, 1998
Senior - North Carolina St
Point Guard
6'1" 180 lbs
~6'2" ws ~8'0" sr
Jun 14, 1999
Junior - DePaul
Power Forward/Center
6'9" 220 lbs
7'1" ws ~8'11" sr
Sep 17, 1999
Senior - Kansas
Center
6'11" 274 lbs
7'7" ws ~9'4.5" sr
Sep 20, 1999
Sophomore - Minnesota
Center
6'10" 240 lbs
7'3" ws ~9'1" sr
Jan 21, 1997
Senior - Virginia
PF/Center
6'9" 230 lbs
7'3.5" ws ~9' sr
Nov 29, 1997
Junior - Kentucky
Center
6'11" 247 lbs
~7'4" ws ~9'1" sr
Sep 20, 1997
Senior - William & Mary
Center
6'10" 253 lbs
~7'2" ws ~9' sr
Jan 8, 1999
Junior - Auburn
Center
6'11" 260 lbs
~7'4.5" ws ~9'2" sr
Sep 18, 1997
Senior - Louisville
Center
6'10" 260 lbs
~7'4" ws ~9' sr
May 3, 1997
Senior - Xavier
PF/Center
6'9" 238 lbs
~6'11" ws ~8'10" sr