HEIC is the better format on paper: an iPhone photo saved as HEIC is usually around half the size of the same photo as JPG, with no difference you can see. JPG is the better format for sharing, because it opens on every phone, computer, browser and web form. Keep HEIC on your phone, convert a copy to JPG when a photo leaves the Apple world, and use PNG only for screenshots and graphics. The test numbers, the limits of each format and a short rule of thumb are in this comparison of HEIC and JPG file size and compatibility.
In a test of 17 real photos from October 2026, at JPEG quality 92, the JPG of an iPhone photo was 1.8 times the size of the HEIC (median). Ten iPhone photos took 17.4 MB as HEIC and 26.4 MB as JPG. Samsung and Sony cameras compress HEIC much more lightly, so there the JPG came out about the same size, from 0.7 to 1.3 times.
Both formats are lossy, so converting encodes the picture once more. The JPGs scored a median SSIM of 0.991 against the HEIC, where 1.0 means identical, and at normal sizes they were hard to tell apart. Resolution and EXIF data stay the same. What a JPG has no room for is the HDR glow from a gain map on recent iPhones, color depth above 8 bit, Live Photo motion and depth maps. Convert once from the HEIC original rather than resaving the same JPG again and again. The GPS location is kept too, so remove the location before posting photos publicly.
Compatibility is where JPG wins. Only Safari displays HEIC in a browser. Chrome, Firefox and Edge do not. Windows 10 needs the free HEIF Image Extensions plus HEVC Video Extensions, usually about 0.99 USD, from the Microsoft Store. Windows 11 usually has HEIF support preinstalled. Photoshop opens HEIC but cannot save it. Discord does not support it, and many web forms reject files with the .heic extension. Email previews are where HEIC fails most often: save the attachment first, then open it in a viewer or convert it.
iPhones from the iPhone 7 onward have shot HEIC by default since iOS 11 in 2017, and Samsung Galaxy phones do the same when High efficiency pictures is on. Switching the camera back to JPG affects only new photos, which will then take about twice the space. Photos you already have stay HEIC.
PNG is lossless and supports transparency, so it is right for screenshots, logos, diagrams and anything with text. For camera photos it is the wrong choice. In the same test the PNG was 4.3 times the size of the JPG and 5.8 times the HEIC, and it looked no better, because it cannot restore detail the camera already discarded. If you need a lossless copy for editing, convert to PNG. A HEIC file is an image, not a program, and opening one on an up to date device is as safe as opening a JPG.
The practical rule is short. Keep the HEIC original in your library. When a form, a lab or a Windows PC without the extensions needs a copy, convert once and stop there. An online converter can take a batch of up to 60 photos, keep full resolution and leave your originals untouched. Built in tools such as Preview on a Mac work too, but they are slower when you have a folder to get through.