Paper Review
OSTERTAG Victor and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ Alejandro
Friday, 13th October
A Cooperative Parallel Search-Based Software Engineering Approach for Code-Smells Detection
Wael Kessentini, Marouane Kessentini, Houari Sahraoui, Slim Bechikh and Ali Ouni
by
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Summary
Code Smells
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Bad practices in source code
Errors and bugs in the final product
Maintenance amounts
to 90% of the cost
of a software
The algorithm
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Algorithm 1
Example of good practices
Algorithm 2
Example of code-smells
Code to
analyze
If they agree, this is a code-smell
Testing
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Open-source codes
Input them in the algorithm
Compare the results to benchmarks
Good points
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Beginner friendly
Explain almost everything
No need to know about the subject
Good points
Easy subject
If you coded once, you understand it
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Good points
Interesting problem
Massive improvements
Spend less money, get more time
Trendy methods
More readers for the journal
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Good points
Catchy Introduction
Great results
Bad points
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Bad points
Graphs are hard to read
No space left in the page.
It is full!
Almost no spacing anywhere
2 columns but there is only text
Not welcoming
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Akward Positions
Why start here?
Why a graph in the middle?
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Small mistake
Conclusion
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
Requires minor correction
Paper Review
OSTERTAG and RUIZ RODRIGUEZ
The verdict
Great content
Improvable presentation
