"AFICIONADOS"

Microsoft Timeline

Microsoft Competitive Landscape

"2007, the 1st iPhone launched, MS had close to 100% share in personal computing market"

  • Consumer started using converged function devices (smartphones) for basic computing tasks like internet browsing
  • Launch of smartphones with OS like Apple's iOS and Google's Android transformed the smartphone market into mobile ecosystem
  • Apple and Google emerged as dominant players and MS market share plummeted to 50%

Industrial Dynamics: Impact on NOKIA

  • Nokia moved too slowly
  • Hurting on both ends' other manufacturers like HTC & Micromax was eating low end market
  • Internal politics in top management
  • R&D teams were working independently and trying to get attention of higher management
  • Nokia didn't have the panache

1343

Strategic Alliance

  • 11th Feb, 2011
  • Nokia to adopt Microsoft's Windows phone OS
  • Microsoft to support Nokia financially and technically to build up Windows phone ecosystem 

REASONS

  • Lack of uptake momentum of the new Windows phone ecosystem
  • Alliance to fulfill each other's needs
  • Rapid decline of Nokia market share

Objectives

  • To stop the decline and eventually grow the market share in the global smartphone market
  • To make it a three-horse race 
  • To benefit from savings in R&D expenditure and marketing support
  • Synergy

Alliance

Horizontal diversification

  • Through this strategic alliance Nokia underwent product development
  • Besides this MS underwent market penetration and market development
  • This strategic alliance is bilateral collaborative arrangement which is contractual in nature

Nature of Strategic Alliance

Ansoff's Growth Matrix

Perspective 

Inside Out perspective

  • Resources over market
  • Strength driven
  • Resource base and activity system
  • Adaptation of environment
  • Attaining distinctive resources
  • Building resource base

Business Lifecycle

Integration of Products and Services - Synergy

  • Alliance maximize the utilization rate of complementary assets and synergy
  1. Microsoft Bing Maps to adopt rich geographical database of Nokia Maps while nokia would leverage MS Bing's search engine 
  2. MS to offer Nokia software development tools to develop software apps
  3. Nokia to integrate its billing payment arrangement in Windows phone products
  4. ​Microsoft market place to be the sole application and content 'store'

Product Management & Innovation

  • Nokia restructured its group executive board, directly reporting to Stephen Elop
  • Microsoft windows phone administered under a separate Entertainment & Devices Division, reporting to Steve Ballmer, CEO MS
  • Both organized regular training sessions and workshops for engineers and sales employees around the globe

Result of Alliance - Nokia Lumia 800

Product Basis

  • Price: Rs.29,999/-
  • OS: Windows 7.5 Mango
  • Processor: 1.4 GHz Scorpion processor
  • Camera: 8 MP Carl Zeiss Optics, Dual LED flash
  • Memory: 16 GB storage, 512 MB RAM
  • Battery: 1450mAh Li-Ion
  • Screen: 3.7 inches

Operational Performance

  • In 2013 (2 yrs. since Lumia 800 launch), windows phone had become most rapid growing platform with european market exceeding 10% market share
  • Windows phone was shipped more than iphone in 24 countries across South America, Europe, Asia and Africa
  • Nokia attracted early adopters to try out the windows phone platform by bringing together innovation and unique competitive features such as camera and imaging technologies

Two Turkeys Don't make an Eagle

  • Unfortunately the partnership couldn't yield much; Windows phone just had 3.7% share of smartphone market & Nokia didn't feature in top 5 global vendor list
  • Vicious circle: Consumers didn't buy as it had very few apps and developers didn't target it because very few consumers owned one

Reasons

  • Business Paradox
  • Corporate Paradox
  • Fit vs Stretch

Why Acquisition? 

  • It seemed cheaper for microsoft to buy a hardware manufacturer than to design and build a smartphone from scratch.
  • They could have acquired other hardware manufacturer like Motorola Mobility but they acquired Nokia because it already ran MS Window OS 
  • OEM model alone is expensive
  • Evidently, It reduces friction
  • 8500 Patents got handy

Acquisition Failure 

"This acquisition does not address why Windows phone has not been successful so far in driving big-time market share. it's not a resource gap at Nokia. It's not a proximal issue between Nokia & Microsoft. The problem with Windows phone is that it has been in catch-up mode for years, unable to come up with the killer feature"

 

  • Microsoft Corp. reported its largest-ever quarterly net loss (2015), hurt by a $7.5 billion writedown after the purchase of Nokia’s handset unit failed to rescue the software maker’s mobile business

Repercussions

  • It would cut 7,800 jobs, or nearly 7 percent of its workforce
  • The net loss in the fourth quarter, which ended June 30,2015, amounted to $3.2 billion, and sales fell 5.1 percent to $22.2 billion

Recommendations

  • Microsoft should allow Android apps to run on Windows phone
  • Improving Microsoft standing as an innovator
  • Take all possible measures to defend the enterprise. Sales of Microsoft software & services to businesses remain to be bright spot
  • Reduce complexities and focus on critical areas. for example- Bing & One Drive
  • Make the perspective outside-in
  • Rebuild its mobile OS around Windows 10 & focus on marketing the striking features rather than comprehensive mobile platform it lacks, since Windows phone users are the only one to carry a full Windows PC in their pocket

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-nW7DxZalQ

References

  • Nokia - Microsoft Alliance: Joining forces in the smartphones war Rao A. Srinivasa
  • In- class lectures by Prof. Tawfiq Elahi
  • The Microsoft-Nokia Strategic Alliance Amanda H.C. Lam, Warwick University, U.K.
  • Article By Keizer Gregg. "Monumental mistake by former CEO Steve Ballmer"
  • www.wired.com Article by Alexander Chang
  • http://uk.reuters.com/article/us-microsoft-redundancies

Thank You

Akanksha Goel

Akshay Agarwal

Anuja Kulkarni

Amitansh Kumar Singh

Chirag Sharma

Jonty Basetia

Suraj Roy

Yash Pokharna

Submitted to:

Prof. Tawfiq Elahi

Microsoft Nokia Alliance

By Chirag Sharma

Microsoft Nokia Alliance

  • 147