Competitive Equilibrium in the Edgeworth Box
Christopher Makler
Stanford University Department of Economics
Econ 51: Lecture 6
Today's Agenda
- Review of Week 1: exchange optimization; net demand and supply
- Review of last time: the Edgeworth Box framework
- Trading in the Edgeworth Box at a common price ratio
- Net demand and net supply
- Solving for the equilibrium price ratio
- Alison and Bob example
- General Cobb-Douglas
- Application to borrowing and lending
- First and second welfare theorems
Review: Optimization from an Endowment (Lecture 2)
Bob has the Cobb-Douglas utility function u(x1,x2)=x1x2 and an endowment of (8, 8)
Cobb-Douglas trick: this is a utility function of the form u(x1,x2)=x1ax2b with a=b=1
x1∗(p1,p2)=a+ba×p1m
x_1^*(p_1,p_2) = {a \over a + b} \times {m \over p_1}
=21×p1m
= {1 \over 2} \times {m \over p_1}
Since Bob has an endowment of (8,8), his "income" m is the value of that endowment
m=p1e1+p2e2
m = p_1e_1 + p_2e_2
=8p1+32
= 8p_1 + 32
x1B(p1)=21×p18p1+32
x_1^B(p_1) = {1 \over 2} \times {8p_1 + 32 \over p_1}
=4+p116
= 4 + {16 \over p_1}
For this entire example, let's fix p2=4.
As we go through this example, work with a friend to solve it as well for Alison,
who has an endowment of (12,2).
The total quantity of a good
you want to consume (i.e. end up with)
at different prices.
Gross Demand
The transaction you want to engage in
(the amount you want to buy or sell)
at different prices.
Net Demand
x1∗(p1,p2,e1,e2)
x_1^*(p_1,p_2,e_1,e_2)
x1∗(p1,p2,e1,e2)−e1
x_1^*(p_1,p_2,e_1,e_2) - e_1
x1B(p1,p2)=4+p116
x_1^B(p_1,p_2) = 4 + {16 \over p_1}
Bob has the Cobb-Douglas utility function u(x1,x2)=x1x2 and an endowment of (8, 8)
ND1∗(p1,p2)=4+p116−8
ND_1^*(p_1,p_2) = 4 + {16 \over p_1} - 8
=p116−4
= {16 \over p_1} - 4
Bob’s net demand = x1∗−e1
\text{Bob's net demand = }x_1^* - e_1
When is this positive?
=p116−4
= \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
p116−4>0
\tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4 > 0
p1<4
p_1 < 4
p116>4
\tfrac{16}{p_1} > 4
So, Bob wants to buy good 1 when p1<4, and sell it when p1>4.
Remember that his utility function is u(x1,x2)=x1x2, his endowment is (8,8), and p2=4.
MRS at endowment =
Price ratio =
x1x2
{x_2 \over x_1}
=88
= {8 \over 8}
=1
= 1
p2p1
{p_1 \over p_2}
=4p1
= {p_1 \over 4}
Bob's MRS at his endowment is
Bob's net demand is
Bob
Endowment: (8,8)
Utility function: u(x1,x2)=x1x2
Bob's gross demand for good 1 is:
Bob
Endowment: (12, 2)
Utility function: u(x1,x2)=x1x2
Alison's gross demand for good 1 is:
Alison
x1B(p1)=4+p116
x_1^B(p_1) = 4 + \tfrac{16}{p_1}
MRS=x1x2=88=1
MRS = \tfrac{x_2}{x_1} = \tfrac{8}{8} = 1
ND1B(p1)=p116−4
ND_1^B(p_1) = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
Alison's MRS at her endowment is:
Alison's net demand is:
x1A(p1)=6+p14
x_1^A(p_1) = 6 + \tfrac{4}{p_1}
MRS=x1x2=122=61
MRS = \tfrac{x_2}{x_1} = \tfrac{2}{12} = \tfrac{1}{6}
ND1A(p1)=p14−6
ND_1^A(p_1) = \tfrac{4}{p_1} - 6
From Bundles to Allocations
- A bundle is a vector of goods
consumed by an individual agent. - An allocation is a vector of bundles
consumed by multiple agents.
From Bundles to Allocations
From Bundles to Allocations
From Bundles to Allocations
Trade in the Edgeworth Box
- Suppose both agents believe they can trade at some price ratio p1/p2.
- Then they share a common budget line in the Edgeworth Box.
...but where do they want to trade to?
Preferences in the Edgeworth Box
What does the "lens" of overlap represent?
How is the existence of this lens related to
the agents' marginal rate of substitution (MRS) at point X?
Bob's MRS at his endowment is
Bob
Bob
Alison
MRS=x1x2=88=1
MRS = \tfrac{x_2}{x_1} = \tfrac{8}{8} = 1
Alison's MRS at her endowment is:
MRS=x1x2=122=61
MRS = \tfrac{x_2}{x_1} = \tfrac{2}{12} = \tfrac{1}{6}
Alison wants to sell good 1 if:
Bob wants to buy good 1 if:
p2p1>61
{p_1 \over p_2} > {1 \over 6}
p2p1<1
{p_1 \over p_2} < 1
61
{1 \over 6}
1
1
p2p1
{p_1 \over p_2}
Between these two price ratios, Alison wants to sell good 1 and Bob wants to buy good 1.
Bob's gross demand for good 1 is:
Bob
Alison's gross demand for good 1 is:
Alison
x1B(p1)=4+p116
x_1^B(p_1) = 4 + \tfrac{16}{p_1}
x1A(p1)=6+p14
x_1^A(p_1) = 6 + \tfrac{4}{p_1}
p1
p_1
x1A
x_1^A
x1B
x_1^B
1
1
10
10
20
20
2
2
8
8
12
12
4
4
7
7
8
8
Net Demand and Supply
- The gross demands tell us where each agents wants to trade to at any given price ratio.
- We can think about this same data in terms of net demand and net supply.
Bob's gross demand for good 1 is:
Alison's gross demand for good 1 is:
x1B(p1)=4+p116
x_1^B(p_1) = 4 + \tfrac{16}{p_1}
x1A(p1)=6+p14
x_1^A(p_1) = 6 + \tfrac{4}{p_1}
p1
p_1
x1A
x_1^A
x1B
x_1^B
1
1
10
10
20
20
2
2
8
8
12
12
4
4
7
7
8
8
His net demand for good 1 is:
Her net supply of good 1 is:
D1B(p1)=x1B(p1)−8=p116−4
D_1^B(p_1) = x_1^B(p_1) - 8 = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
S1A(p1)=12−x1A(p1)=6−p14
S_1^A(p_1) = 12 - x_1^A(p_1) = 6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
S1
S_1
2
2
D1
D_1
12
12
Bob demands 12
Alison supplies 2
Bob's gross demand for good 1 is:
Alison's gross demand for good 1 is:
x1B(p1)=4+p116
x_1^B(p_1) = 4 + \tfrac{16}{p_1}
x1A(p1)=6+p14
x_1^A(p_1) = 6 + \tfrac{4}{p_1}
p1
p_1
x1A
x_1^A
x1B
x_1^B
1
1
10
10
20
20
2
2
8
8
12
12
4
4
7
7
8
8
His net demand for good 1 is:
Her net supply of good 1 is:
D1B(p1)=x1B(p1)−8=p116−4
D_1^B(p_1) = x_1^B(p_1) - 8 = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
S1A(p1)=12−x1A(p1)=6−p14
S_1^A(p_1) = 12 - x_1^A(p_1) = 6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
S1
S_1
2
2
D1
D_1
12
12
Bob demands 4
Alison supplies 4
4
4
4
4
Bob's gross demand for good 1 is:
Alison's gross demand for good 1 is:
x1B(p1)=4+p116
x_1^B(p_1) = 4 + \tfrac{16}{p_1}
x1A(p1)=6+p14
x_1^A(p_1) = 6 + \tfrac{4}{p_1}
p1
p_1
x1A
x_1^A
x1B
x_1^B
1
1
10
10
20
20
2
2
8
8
12
12
4
4
7
7
8
8
His net demand for good 1 is:
Her net supply of good 1 is:
D1B(p1)=x1B(p1)−8=p116−4
D_1^B(p_1) = x_1^B(p_1) - 8 = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
S1A(p1)=12−x1A(p1)=6−p14
S_1^A(p_1) = 12 - x_1^A(p_1) = 6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
S1
S_1
2
2
5
5
D1
D_1
12
12
0
0
(Bob demands 0)
Alison supplies 5
4
4
4
4
p1
p_1
1
1
2
2
4
4
Bob's net demand for good 1 is:
Alison's net supply of good 1 is:
D1B(p1)=p116−4
D_1^B(p_1) = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
S1A(p1)=6−p14
S_1^A(p_1) = 6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
S1
S_1
2
2
5
5
D1
D_1
12
12
0
0
4
4
4
4
Solving for Equilibrium
Bob's net demand for good 1 is:
Alison's net supply of good 1 is:
D1B(p1)=p116−4
D_1^B(p_1) = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
S1A(p1)=6−p14
S_1^A(p_1) = 6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
Just like we always do, set these equal to one another and solve for the equilibrium price!
S1A(p1)
S_1^A(p_1)
=
=
D1B(p1)
D_1^B(p_1)
6−p14
6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
=
=
p116−4
\tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
10
10
=
=
p120
\tfrac{20}{p_1}
p1
p_1
=
=
2
2
Bob's net demand for good 1 is:
Alison's net supply of good 1 is:
D1B(p1)=p116−4
D_1^B(p_1) = \tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
S1A(p1)=6−p14
S_1^A(p_1) = 6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
Just like we always do, set these equal to one another and solve for the equilibrium price!
S1A(p1)
S_1^A(p_1)
=
=
D1B(p1)
D_1^B(p_1)
6−p14
6 - \tfrac{4}{p_1}
=
=
p116−4
\tfrac{16}{p_1} - 4
10
10
=
=
p120
\tfrac{20}{p_1}
p1
p_1
=
=
2
2
Solving for general Cobb-Douglas utility functions
u(x1,x2)=alnx1+(1−a)lnx2
u(x_1,x_2) = a \ln x_1 + (1-a) \ln x_2
u(x1,x2)=blnx1+(1−b)lnx2
u(x_1,x_2) = b \ln x_1 + (1-b) \ln x_2
The parameter a measures how much A likes good 1,
and the parameter b measures how much B likes good 1.
Solving for general Cobb-Douglas utility functions
u(x1,x2)=alnx1+(1−a)lnx2
u(x_1,x_2) = a \ln x_1 + (1-a) \ln x_2
u(x1,x2)=blnx1+(1−b)lnx2
u(x_1,x_2) = b \ln x_1 + (1-b) \ln x_2
The parameter a measures how much A likes good 1,
and the parameter b measures how much B likes good 1.
Formula for the equilibrium price ratio:
p2p1=(1−a)e1A+(1−b)e1Bae2A+be2B
{p_1 \over p_2} = \frac{a e_2^A + be_2^B}{(1-a)e_1^A + (1-b)e_1^B}
In our example with Alison and Bob, we had: a=21,e1A=12,e2A=2;b=21,e1B=8,e2B=8:
p2p1=21(12)+21(8)21(2)+21(8)
{p_1 \over p_2} = \frac{{1 \over 2}(2) + {1 \over 2} (8)}{{1 \over 2}(12) + {1 \over 2}(8)}
=105=21
= \frac{5}{10}={1 \over 2}
In this example, both Alison and Bob liked the two goods equally. Why wasn't the price ratio 1?
Solving for general Cobb-Douglas utility functions
u(x1,x2)=alnx1+(1−a)lnx2
u(x_1,x_2) = a \ln x_1 + (1-a) \ln x_2
u(x1,x2)=blnx1+(1−b)lnx2
u(x_1,x_2) = b \ln x_1 + (1-b) \ln x_2
The parameter a measures how much A likes good 1,
and the parameter b measures how much B likes good 1.
Formula for the equilibrium price ratio:
p2p1=(1−a)e1A+(1−b)e1Bae2A+be2B
{p_1 \over p_2} = \frac{a e_2^A + be_2^B}{(1-a)e_1^A + (1-b)e_1^B}
What happens to the relative price of good 1
if people like good 1 more (that is, a and b are higher)?
What happens to the relative price of good 1
if there is more good 1 in the world (that is, e1A and e1B are higher)?
p2p1=(1−a)e1A+(1−b)e1Bae2A+be2B
{p_1 \over p_2} = \frac{a e_2^A + be_2^B}{(1-a)e_1^A + (1-b)e_1^B}
In competitive equilibrium in an exchange economy,
the price ratio reflects two fundamental things:
the preferences of the agents, and
the relative scarcity of the goods.
Fundamental Theorems of Welfare Economics
- First Welfare Theorem: If an allocation X∗ is a competitive equilibrium, then it is Pareto efficient.
- Second Welfare Theorem: When preferences are convex, any Pareto efficient allocation is an equilibrium for some set of prices and some endowment.
The First Welfare Theorem
- Formally: If an allocation X∗ is a competitive equilibrium, then it is Pareto efficient.
- Intuitively: Markets are efficient. If you just let everyone do what's best for themselves, you end up with a Pareto efficient outcome. Libertarianism FTW!
Since Anthony's preferred set is entirely on this set of the budget line...
...and Bruno's preferred set is entirely on this side of the budget line...
...then X* must be Pareto efficient!
[. ]
WHAT'S NEXT?
Competitive Equilibrium in the Edgeworth Box Christopher Makler Stanford University Department of Economics Econ 51: Lecture 6
Econ 51 | 06 | Competitive Equilibrium
By Chris Makler
Econ 51 | 06 | Competitive Equilibrium
Efficiency and Equity in the Edgeworth Box
- 362
