# Fusion Energy Nuclear Physics 303 course

Presented at Sheffield University on 19/2/2018

by  Jonathan Shimwell

Image by Volker Steger

by Jonathan Shimwell

Fusion Energy, Physics 303 course

# Objectives

• Why and when
• Reasons for selecting the DT reaction
• Methods of achieving nuclear fusion
• Lawson criteria
• Fusion technology

by Jonathan Shimwell

Fusion Energy, Physics 303 course

# Fusion energy has excellent credentials

• Safe (no run away chain reactions)
• High energy density (337GJ/g)
• Clean (reaction waste product is helium)
• Low Carbon (no CO2 emitted during operation)
• Produces no long lived radioactivity (Only activated materials)
• An abundant and distributed fuel source (Lithium and Deuterium)

by Jonathan Shimwell

Fusion Energy, Physics 303 course

# When will fusion be achieved?

• Funding
• The demand for a new energy source
• Political will
• Scientific and engineering capacity
• Unknown unknowns

"Fusion will be ready when society needs it"

Lev Artsimovich, Father of the Tokamak

by Jonathan Shimwell

Fusion Energy, Physics 303 course

# The need for a new energy source

Data source WEC, BP, USGS and WNA data from presentation by  Steven Cowley

# What is fusion

• A fusion reaction is the joining of two smaller atoms to form heavier ones.
• A large amount of energy is released during this process .

Deuterium (D)

Tritium (T)

Helium 4

3.5MeV

1/5 of the energy

Neutron

14.1MeV

4/5 of the energy

Helium 5

17.6MeV

# Energy emitted from nuclear reactions

• Calculation of fusion energy  from binding energy

H3 + H2 = He4 + n

Binding energy before = 3 x 2.83 + 2 x 1.11

Binding energy after = 4 x 7.07
Difference in binding energy is 17.57 MeV

• Calculation of fission energy from mass difference

U235 + n= Ba145 + Kr87 + 4n

Mass before = 235.04393u + 1.00866u

Mass after = 144.92752u + 86.91335u + 4 x 1.00866u

Mass difference = 0.17708u = 164.95MeV

proton mass = 1.672623E-27 kg

neutron mass = 1.674929E-27 kg

1 atomic mass unit = 1.660540E-27 kg

# Maximum energy emitted from fission and fusion per gram

17.6 MeV emitted per DT fusion

Assuming every D reacts with a T.
1 gram of material.

~200MeV emitted per U235 fission

Assuming 100% U235 enrichment .
Assuming ever U235 fissions.
Ignoring decay heat.
1 gram of material.

number\ of\ moles =\frac{mass}{molar \ mass}
$number\ of\ moles =\frac{mass}{molar \ mass}$
0.2 =\frac{1}{5}
$0.2 =\frac{1}{5}$
number \ of \ atoms = number\ of\ moles \times Avogadro's \ constant
$number \ of \ atoms = number\ of\ moles \times Avogadro's \ constant$
0.0042 =\frac{1}{235}
$0.0042 =\frac{1}{235}$
0.0042 \times 6.02 \times 10^{23} = 2.56\times 10^{21}
$0.0042 \times 6.02 \times 10^{23} = 2.56\times 10^{21}$
0.2 \times 6.02 \times 10^{23} = 1.204\times 10^{23}
$0.2 \times 6.02 \times 10^{23} = 1.204\times 10^{23}$
1g\ gram\ of\ DT\ fuel\ 1.1\times 10^{24}\ J
$1g\ gram\ of\ DT\ fuel\ 1.1\times 10^{24}\ J$
1g\ gram\ of\ U^{235}fuel\ 0.5\times 10^{24}\ J
$1g\ gram\ of\ U^{235}fuel\ 0.5\times 10^{24}\ J$

# Typical fusion reactions

H2 + H2 = H3 + H1                  Q=4MeV

H2 + H2 = He3 + n                   Q=3.3MeV

H2 + He3 = He4 + H1              Q=18.3MeV

N14 + H1 = O15                       Q=7.35MeV

H2 + H1 = He3                         Q=5.49MeV

C12 + H1 = N13                        Q=12.86MeV

He3 + He3 = He4 + 2 H1         Q=1.95MeV

C13 + H1 = N14                        Q=7.55MeV

H1 + H1 = H2                            Q=0.42MeV

N15 + H1 = C12 + He4             Q=4.96MeV

H2 + H3 = He4 +n                   Q=17.6MeV

# Fusion cross section

• The DT reaction has a higher probability of occurring
• The DT reaction has a lower threshold temperature
• The DT reaction releases large amounts of energy 17.6MeV

Magnetic

confinement

Gravitational

confinement

Inertial

confinement

# Gravitation confinement

• The repulsive coulomb force is overcome by gravitational forces and tunneling

• Extremely large masses are required as gravity is a relatively weak force.

Indirect drive

Direct drive

# Magnetic Confinement

Poloidal and toroidal magnets

# Magnetic Confinement

ITER reactor

800m3 plasma volume

500MW thermal

DEMO reactor

1000-3500m3 plasma volume

4000MW thermal

JET reactor

80m3 plasma volume

16MW thermal

Tore Supra

25m3 plasma volume

0MW thermal

# Ignition

The point where a fusion reaction becomes self-sustaining instead of requiring a constant input of energy. In the case of DT fusion the plasma is heated by the energetic alpha particle that is emitted during fusion reactions. This is also known as self heated plasma

# Lawson criteria

The lawson criteria defines the general requirements (temperature, density and confinement time) of a reactor to reach a self sustaining reaction (ignition).

n_e\tau \geq
$n_e\tau \geq$
12K_BT_e
$12K_BT_e$
Q<\sigma v>
$Q<\sigma v>$

Confinement time

Boltzmann constant

Temperature of electrons

Number density of electrons

Energy released per fission

Cross section of reaction

Average velocity of ions

# Derivation of Lawson Criterion for DT fusion

\tau = \frac{w}{P_{loss}}
$\tau = \frac{w}{P_{loss}}$
w = \int_{}^{}( \frac{3}{2}k_Bn_eT_e+\frac{3}{2}k_Bn_DT_D +\frac{3}{2}k_Bn_tT_t)dV
$w = \int_{}^{}( \frac{3}{2}k_Bn_eT_e+\frac{3}{2}k_Bn_DT_D +\frac{3}{2}k_Bn_tT_t)dV$
n_e = n_{ions} = n_D + n_t
$n_e = n_{ions} = n_D + n_t$
w =\frac{3}{2}k_BT_e(n_e+0.5n_e+0.5n_e)V
$w =\frac{3}{2}k_BT_e(n_e+0.5n_e+0.5n_e)V$
P_{loss} = \frac{3k_BT_en_eV}{\tau}
$P_{loss} = \frac{3k_BT_en_eV}{\tau}$
R = n_Dn_t<\sigma_fv>V
$R = n_Dn_t<\sigma_fv>V$
RQ = n_Dn_t<\sigma_fv>VQ
$RQ = n_Dn_t<\sigma_fv>VQ$
RQ \geq P_{loss}
$RQ \geq P_{loss}$
\frac{1}{4}n_e^2<\sigma_fv>QV \geq \frac{3k_BT_en_eV}{\tau}
$\frac{1}{4}n_e^2<\sigma_fv>QV \geq \frac{3k_BT_en_eV}{\tau}$
n_e\tau \geq \frac{12k_BT_e}{Q<\sigma_fv>}
$n_e\tau \geq \frac{12k_BT_e}{Q<\sigma_fv>}$
V = volume
$V = volume$
v = velocity
$v = velocity$
R = reaction \ rate
$R = reaction \ rate$
w = stored \ energy \ in \ plasma
$w = stored \ energy \ in \ plasma$
P_{loss} = rate \ of \ energy \ loss
$P_{loss} = rate \ of \ energy \ loss$
k_B = Boltzmann \ constant
$k_B = Boltzmann \ constant$
\sigma_f = fusion \ cross \ section
$\sigma_f = fusion \ cross \ section$
\tau = confinement \ time
$\tau = confinement \ time$
T = temperature \ of \ tritium (T_t), \ deuterium (T_D), \ electrons \ (T_e), \ ions \ (T_i)
$T = temperature \ of \ tritium (T_t), \ deuterium (T_D), \ electrons \ (T_e), \ ions \ (T_i)$
n = number \ density \ of \ tritium (n_t), \ deuterium \ (n_D), \ electrons \ (n_e)
$n = number \ density \ of \ tritium (n_t), \ deuterium \ (n_D), \ electrons \ (n_e)$
Q = energy \ released \ by \ reaction
$Q = energy \ released \ by \ reaction$
RQ = \frac{1}{4}n_e^2<\sigma_fv>QV
$RQ = \frac{1}{4}n_e^2<\sigma_fv>QV$

# Breeder blankets

• To generate sufficient tritium fuel to sustain the reactor.
• To convert kinetic energy of the neutrons to thermal energy.
• To shield the exterior components from neutrons.

# Fuel Cycle

Key reactions in breeder blankets

Questions

Which isotope is depleted?
Why at the front?
What is the best isotope for the front?

Li^6 + n = He^4 + H^3
$Li^6 + n = He^4 + H^3$
Li^7 + n = He^4 + H^3 + n
$Li^7 + n = He^4 + H^3 + n$
Be^9 + n = 2He^4 + 2n
$Be^9 + n = 2He^4 + 2n$
1\times 10^{21}
$1\times 10^{21}$
neutrons
$neutrons$
per second
$per second$

# Fuel Cycle

Neutron spectra at different depths in the blanket.

Neutrons are moderated by the material and lose energy.

Neutrons are also captured by some reactions.

# Fuel Cycle - neutron multiplication

Target

Nuclide

n,2n

n,g

n,p

n,pn

n,d

n,t

n,nd

n,a

n,He3

n,pd

n = neutron

g = gamma

t = tritium

p = proton

d = deuterium

He = helium

Common neutron induced reactions

Neutron number

Proton number

Atomic number

Percentage of fission products

# EU Roadmap for fusion energy

• 3 main reactors (JET, ITER, DEMO) demonstrating large steps in understanding and performance.

• Many smaller reactors testing, validating and experimenting on different plasma physics regimes, component designs, materials and feeding into the design of larger ground breaking reactors

# Lots of interesting physics to learn

Banana orbits

run away electrons

Stellarators

3D printing components

Neutral particle accelerators

Robotic maintainance

Plasma instabilities such as sausage, kink, balloon and elms

# Further opportunists

Masters Degrees

PhD

Jobs

Fusion Energy Msc
The University of York

European Masters of Science in Nuclear Fusion and Engineering Physics
Organised by the European Commission

The physics and technology of nuclear reactors, MSc
University of Birmingham

Nuclear Energy, MPhil
University of Cambridge

Fusion Doctorial Training Network, PhD Organised by several universities and research organisations.

Doctoral Programme in nuclear fusion science and engineering
Organised by 18 European Universities

Nuclear First Doctorial Training Centre University of Manchester and University of Sheffield.

PhD open days hosted by UKAEA and CCFE with repreentatives from  UK universities

Summer placements, graduate recruitment at Fusion 4 Energy in Barcelona

Fusenet the European fusion education network with funding oppertunities

#### Fusion Energy

By Jonathan Shimwell

# Fusion Energy

Sheffield University Nuclear Physics 303 course 2018

• 260