Why are web forms so hard?

And how re-frame can help(?)

WORK IN PROGRESS - IGNORE

Easy, just set/get  .value of DOM element!


No, wait: This is react: where to store the value?

 

Re-frame: Store in the app-db at some location

Input w/ placeholder

First name

Lots of extra state

First name

  • Value
  • Validation
  • Error Message
  • Coercion
  • Focus
  • Cursor pos
  • Selection
  • Placeholder
  • Label
  • Ready to use?
  • Enabled
  • Visible
  • Tab order
  • Events: on change/blur/keyUp

Re-frame: err store *some* of it in app-db

Form Submission Time!

  • Simple web forms: POST to an endpoint. Easy!
  • The  "better(?)" way: Collect all form data, massage it and send it to endpoint as JSON/EDN
  • Oops, we need extra data on top of the user provided one to make the submission
  • Submission failed: Show error messages in various ways
  • Prevent double submissions

 

Re-frame: Write event handler. Get data from app. Ask for http-xhrio effect to run.

If you really really really have to: inject subscription data into event handler. Now your view subscriptions are tied to form submission...

(inc difficulty) => Selects

  • Context-menus, popup menus, drop-down boxes, select boxes, picklists etc.
  • User selects from a static list. Easy!
  • Now the list is dynamic and retrieved asynchronously
    • new state: List ready to use? (i.e. list of choices is available)
  • Different conditions that trigger retrieval of new list
    • some other field changed
    • some time has passed
    • on form init
  • De-bouncing: Prevent unnecessary retrievals

Re-frame: Err, event handlers and subscriptions. Smile and wave

(inc (inc difficulty)) => Interactive Search

  • Search field with async results
  • No simple HTML-only solution
  • Minimal prefix, de-bouncing: Be nice to your endpoint
  • Re-paint when new data is arriving without interrupting the user
  • Send more results via pagination

Re-frame: err events and subscriptions

Why are forms so hard?

By Jochen Bedersdorfer

Why are forms so hard?

  • 446