Revision Strategies
Editing vs. Revising
Editing
- Grammar
- Spelling
- Sentence structure
- Punctuation
Revision
- Adding new thoughts/claims/ideas
- Clarifying or expanding on existing ideas
- Using more precise, descriptive language
- Cutting extraneous material
Revision
- Considers the whole of the paper
- strengths and weaknesses
- areas for expansion or cutting
- argument as a whole—big picture
- Ask questions—will the reader understand? What will be confusing or misleading? Where can you add, expand, clarify, or excise material for understanding?
- Purpose: expansion and clarification of ideas; not correction
Revision = Re-visioning
Questions to Ask in Revision
- Does the paper respond to the assignment?
- Does it respond to all questions and prompts?
- Is the argument clear? Where can you clarify terms or ideas?
- Do you have an argument? Are you sure it's not observation?
- Do any ideas need developing?
- Do you need more specific textual evidence? Research support?
- Is evidence specific and precise rather than general?
Questions to Ask in Revision
- Do the main ideas lead logically and clearly from one to the next?
- Do you have clear transitions between paragraphs and ideas?
- Once you have revised and clarified the argument: does your thesis accurately specify your argument?
- Will the reader be able to follow and understand your argument?
- Are all elements of your paper necessary and doing the work of supporting your argument?
- Did you fully explain main points and connections?
Read aloud
Wait to Edit
UWC
Revision Strategies
Revision Strategies
By Justin Daugherty
Revision Strategies
- 458