'India calling to the far away towns': 

the call centre labour process and globalization

Author: Phil Taylor and Peter Bain

Jingyu Zhang

Xu Wang

Pan Fu

Siqi Long

Introduction

  • Overseas migration of call centre services (Indian) 
  • Influence Employment (UK and Indian) 
  • Challenge the assumption “off-shoring of voice services” 
  • Seven Parts

Three Modules

  • Taylorized mass-production
  • Professional services
  • Hybrid mass-customization

Work organization & labour process

Two Logics 

  • Cost-efficient 
  • Customer-oriented 

Technologically-driven

High-volume

Low-cost

 

Labour process

Triangular relationship

Customer

Employee

Management

The triangle is not equilateral

 

Weakness

  • Overriding profit: Cost minimization & Profit maximization
  • Tensions
  • Emotional exhaustion 
  • ill-health

Indian Workflows

  • Characteristics: Highly standardized, simple in content, tightly scripted and of short duration 
  • Essence of strategy: Moving up to the value chain 
  • Labour plays Low-value 

Work Organization and Work Experiences

  • Similar labour process 
  • Long working time causes burnout 
  • Highly working pressure causes physical problems 
  • Women are more likely to take heavy responsibilities 
  • Working environment 
  • Differences in statues causes unfair treatment 
  • Differences between expectation and reality 
  • Work and employment conditions generate both familiar and distinctive 
  • forms of resistance 

Indian Call Centre Industry Profile

  • The Indian industry originated in the mid-1990s 
  • In the late-1990s GE established India’s first voice operation 
  • Between 75,000 and 115,000 people were employed in Indian call centres in June 2003 
  • To meet the demands of international clients.  The number of medium-to-large third-party establishments is growing 
  • Migrating companies engage, not just in third-party outsourcing, but also in partnerships, co-sourcing or remote sourcing relationships with Indian suppliers 
  • Companies have invested recently in ‘second tier’ cities 

Political and Economic Contexts

  • The fundamental motive: cost advantage. After the recession, the threshold for convincing people about cost savings has come down 
  • Key attribute: the ability to speak English over 90% of its revenues come from English-speaking geographies (Nasscom, 2003: 56) 
  • Policies  including  the provision of tax incentives and telecoms deregulation have facilitated migration 

Recruitment, Training and Attrition

  • Selection 
  • Training
  • Critical evaluation
  • Attrition rate
  • Positive outlook 
  • People skills 
  • Ability to work under pressure 
  • Grasp different accents 
  • Various cultural nuances 
  • Cultural fit

SELECTION

TRAINING

  • Language and cultural training 
  • Accent training 
  • Transnational dimension

CRITICAL EVALUATION

ATTRITION RATE

Attrition rate (%) = (Number of employees resigned during the month / Average number of employees during the month) x 100

 

where Average number of employees during the month = (Total number of employees at the start of the month + Total number of employees at the end of the month) / 2 

CONCLUSION

THANK YOU

Q&A

india calling centre labour process & globalisation

By longsiqi

india calling centre labour process & globalisation

  • 156