Non-Fungible Tokens

 

Instructors: Andreas Park and Zissis Poulos




 

Agenda for the presentation

  • What is property?
  • What is a non-fungible token?
  • Why bother?

What is property?

History of Property

  • Feudalism: all land belonged to the King who lets it out to tenants.
     
  • Magna Carta: rights of all free citizens to own and inherit property and to be protected from excessive taxes.
     
  • More generally: considered to be a core property of a functioning society
     
  • Not without controversy:
    • La propriété, c'est le vol! Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1840) 
    • Communism=property rights not needed (each to their ability and need)

Recording of Property is a Social Convention

  • If you buy a house, what are you buying?
     
  • You ask your bank to change two ledger entries, transferring a claim on your bank's asset to somebody else.
     
  • You sign a transaction with paper and pencil under the watchful eyes of a notary.
     
  • You take is to the country clerk or property registry and present it there.
  • What do you own?

\(\to\) an entry in the property register

What is an NFT?

sale price: $69,000,000

  • ERC-20: fungible token
     
  • ERC-721: non-fungible
     
  • ERC-1155: mix of both
     
  • can programs lots of properties into tokens... 

Recall: token standards

What is an NFT?

  • "unique" token
  • digital ownership certificate
  • ERC-721 standard (also ERC-1155)

Source: Christophe Spaenjers (Hec Paris) NFTs: Modern Masterpieces—Or Money For Nothing?

Some data

Latest Trend: Wash trading = Tax Loss Harvesting?

recommended reading: "Tax-Loss Harvesting with Cryptocurrencies" Will Cong et al 2022 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4033617

Why bother with NFTs?

History of Property

  • Markets need clear property rights:
    • Before you buy a  good, must know who has the right to sell it
    • Once bought, transfer ownership from the seller to the buyer must be clear.
  • NFTs solve this problem:
    • give parties something they can agree represents ownership
    • make it possible to build markets around new types of transactions
    • \(\to\) buying and selling of products that could never be sold before
    • \(\to\) enable traditional transactions to happen in innovative ways that are more efficient and valuable.

Why bother with an NFT?

  • allows royalty payments
  • could be used in other tools (e-book readers)
  • NFTs can be tokenized (partial ownership)
  • used as collateral in DeFi

Metaverse application

  • ownership in the digital world
  • payment for digital experiences

What are you buying with an NFT?

  • unique ledger entry that refer to a digital object (via metadata)
     
  • bragging rights
     
  • ability to resell the leader entry

What you don't have
 

  • other rights (such as copyright)
     
  • a "better" or more "authentic" copy of the artwork than non-NFT owners

Here's where it's complicated

  • Are you the owner of the artwork?
     
  • What stops you from issuing an NFT on another person's work?
     
  • What ensures continuity of the artwork?
     
  • What retains the link to the object?
     
  • Who ensures the survival of the platform?
     
  • Is there a future market for physical objects?

Why people were excited 

Artists like:

  • normalization of royalties and equity in art
  • new types of contracting
  • early-stage artists can pool risk and share upside
  • investment trusts amount artists
  • new compensation for creative labour
  • could be used in other tools (e-book readers)

further reading: Amy Whitaker (New York University), Fractional Equity In Art: Applications Of Blockchain

Folks in finance like

  • tradeable royalty payments
  • NFTs can be tokenized (partial ownership)
  • used as collateral in DeFi

Metaverse enthusiasts like

  • ownership in the digital world
  • payment for digital experiences

The Future is already happening

Developments: NFTs bring in entirely new ideas to blockchain

  • with NFT in wallet gain access to an online game, chat room, or merchandise store
  • creators connect with NFT holders (https://www.nft.nyc/)
  • Model of active ecosystem-building:​
    • start with an NFT series
    • roadmap with NFT= access to  expanding array of products, activities, and experiences.
    • Revenue back to brand to support new projects
    • \(\to\) value of the NFTs \(\nearrow\)
  • private chat rooms
  • graffiti board
  • high-end merchandise
  • social events incl actual yacht party

real-world benefits like extravagant in-person events.

Opportunity

  • link/purchase of NFTs without crypto
  • \(\to\) already exists in China with Alipay + Conflux
  • But: Ethereum too congested
    \(\to\) opportunity for new chains such as Solana

Further reading: How NFTs Create Value
by Steve Kaczynski and Scott Duke Kominers

https://hbr.org/2021/11/how-nfts-create-value, Nov 10, 2021

@financeUTM

andreas.park@rotman.utoronto.ca

slides.com/ap248

sites.google.com/site/parkandreas/

youtube.com/user/andreaspark2812/

Non-Fungible Tokens

By Andreas Park

Non-Fungible Tokens

  • 776