history and social media:
an archiving failure?

frédéric clavert
@inactinique@hcommons.social

frederic.clavert@uni.lu

inactinique.net

  1. Why archiving social media posts?
  2. Case studies
  3. different ways to collect tweets

Why archiving and analysing social media posts?

Tweets are primary sources

They can help understand

  • how people engage with history and the past
  • how collective memories develop

Archived, they will help future historians understand our present

Anonymised tweets from the night of the Bataclan attacks

About this tweet, see: Joshua Sternfeld, « Historical Understanding in the Quantum Age », Journal of Digital Humanities, 3-2, 2014.

Tweet from the night of the Bataclan attack, with the #portesouvertes hashtag

Which social media?

The ones we can.

 

 

 

  • Facebook/instagram data is hard to collect.
  • Whatsapp / Snapchat are impossible to collect.
  • Twitter/Reddit used to be collectable
  • TikTok?

An application programming interface (API) is a computing interface which defines interactions between multiple software intermediaries.

source: wikipedia

Pitfalls

Who are we studying when collecting and analysing social media data?

 

  • the demographics of social media is complicated (if not impossible) to understand
  • the diversity of social media accounts
    • people, institutions, groups, bots, etc.

What do we study with social media?

  • Information circulation (memetics) where information is understood in a very wide meaning.
    See: Dominique Boullier, « Big data challenges for the social sciences: from society and opinion to replications », arXiv:1607.05034 [cs], 2016.
  • Practices
  • Activism

 

Any other ideas?

Case studies

#ww1 and #covid19

Engaging with the past:
the Centenary of the First World War

  • Unique series of commemoration
  • 2014-2018
  • Throughout Europe and North America

 

9 millions+ tweets collected

Memory in the making: #covid19fr

Background: John Hopkins University coronavirus map. Screenshot (7/7/2020)

Different ways
to collect tweets

Search API (v1.1)

  • You can look for tweets in the past (up to 7 days)
  • You can collect around 3000 tweets per hour
  • No need to get a twitter developper account

Streaming API (v1.1)

  • You can get up to 1% of the firehose (of the tweets published at a precise moment)
  • Only tweets being published / will be published: necessity to anticipate
  • You need a twitte developper account

API v2 academic product track

  • Search
    • 10 millions tweets pro month
    • in the full history of Twitter
    • but...
  • Stream
    • less than the 1%

 

Web scrapping

  • Not Twitter TOS compliant
  • Less metadata
  • But you can get tweets up to 2006 (creation of Twitter)

 

Works now only with the search engine

DSA?

Web archives

useless archive

halted success

our dependence on BigTech

Counterarchiving?

  • Valérie Schafer, Gérôme Truc, Romain Badouard, Lucien Castex et Francesca Musiani, « Paris and Nice terrorist attacks: Exploring Twitter and web archives », Media, War & Conflict, , 2019, p. 1750635219839382.
  • Evelien D’heer, Baptist Vandersmissen, Wesley De Neve, Pieter Verdegem et Rik Van de Walle, « What are we missing? An empirical exploration in the structural biases of hashtag-based sampling on Twitter », First Monday,  22-2, 2017.
  • Martin Grandjean, « A social network analysis of Twitter: Mapping the digital humanities community », Cogent Arts & Humanities, 3-1, 2016, p. 1171458.
  • Michael Zimmer, « The Twitter Archive at the Library of Congress: Challenges for information practice and information policy », First Monday,  20-7, 2015.
  • Shirley A. Williams, Melissa M. Terras et Claire Warwick, « What do people study when they study Twitter? Classifying Twitter related academic papers », Journal of Documentation,  69-3, 2013, p. 384‑410.
  • Danah Boyd, Scott Golder et Gilad Lotan, « Tweet, tweet, retweet: Conversational aspects of retweeting on twitter », IEEE, 2010.
  • Danah M Boyd et Nicole B. Ellison, « Social Network Sites: Definition, History, and Scholarship », Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,  13-1, 2007, p. 210‑230.
  • Hany M. SalahEldeen et Michael L. Nelson, « Losing My Revolution: How Many Resources Shared on Social Media Have Been Lost? », arXiv:1209.3026, , 2012.
  • Jean-Christophe Peyssard, « Archiving Web Content ». https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/cel-02130558/document
  • Ben-David, Anat. 2020. « Counter-Archiving Facebook ». European Journal of Communication, mai, 026732312092206. https://doi.org/10.1177/0267323120922069.
  • Two prez: «How to deal with 4 millions+ tweets when you are not a data scientist» (https://orbilu.uni.lu/handle/10993/35017)
  • and «Twitter data as primary sources for historians: a critical approach» (with S. Papastamkou) (https://orbilu.uni.lu/handle/10993/37070)

history and social media: an archiving failure?

By Frédéric Clavert

history and social media: an archiving failure?

  • 1,231