Gordon Pask &
Alfred Bork

EDUC 131

Shayan Doroudi

University of California, Irvine

Cybernetics

c. 1940s

“the scientific study of control and communication in the animal and the machine.”

- Norbert Weiner

Latinized form of Greek kybernetes “steersman” (metaphorically “guide, governor”), from kybernan “to steer or pilot a ship, direct as a pilot,” figuratively “to guide, govern,” which is of uncertain origin.

Cybernetics

c. 1940s

the study of goal-directed behavior

in any entity

Cybernetics

c. 1940s

the term “feedback” was (probably) popularized by cybernetics

Second-Order Cybernetics

c. 1960s

Second-order cybernetics sees the study of cybernetics as a cybernetic process itself:

  • Cyberneticians are not external objective observers, they are part of the system
  • Cybernetic processes mutually reinforce each other.
  • Two second-order cybernetics theories:
    • Radical Constructivism (von Glasersfeld)

    • Conversation Theory (Pask)

 

AKA New Cybernetics

AKA Cybernetics of Cybernetics

EUCRATES

1955

SAKI

1956

Group Instruction

1962

CASTE

Early 1970s

"There was insufficient storage...in the mini-computer to allow for electronic display of a subject matter, but this was no discouragement to the implementors. The processor simply controlled a row of lights above a row of cubbyholes, each one containing a clipboard with a piece of paper on which the content was printed. The user responded to a lighted cubbyhole by extracting the clipboard and reading the material."

- Paul Pangaro

Pask’s View of Learning

Pask on Skinner's Teaching Machines:

Pask, G. (1961). An approach to cybernetics. Hutchinson & Co.

Pask’s View of Learning

Pask, G. (1961). An approach to cybernetics. Hutchinson & Co.

What is a Conversation?

Person 1

Person 2

Conversation

Person

Machine

Conversation

Machine 1

Machine 2

Conversation

Person
1

Person
1

Conversation

Society
1

Society
2

Conversation

Entailment Structures

Learning Styles

A popular belief is that students have different learning styles (e.g., visual, auditory, reading/writing, and kinesthetic)

and presenting material to students according to their learning style will lead to better learning.

However, researchers have shown that there is little evidence that tailoring instruction to learning styles makes any difference.

For example, see https://youtu.be/rhgwIhB58PA

Learning Styles

Pask was studying learning strategies and styles in the 1970s.
Discovered that students generally use one of two strategies:

serialist - learning step-by-step, picking up individual rules

holist - processing multiple things at once, forming analogies

In several experiments, Pask and colleagues showed that tailoring instruction to a student’s learning style/strategy makes a big difference.

Also discovered two general learning styles:

comprehension learners - likely to use holist strategy, focus on the why

operation learners - likely to use serialist strategy, focus on the how

Alfred Bork

Professor at UCI in Physics and ICS from 1968

Professor in ICS from 1983

Founded the Educational Technology Center

Can access his papers, floppy disks, etc. in the UCI Libraries Archives and Special Collections

Nonlinear Ruler

1962

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

Educational Technology Center

Scientific Reasoning Series

1986

Distance Learning

 We are at a wonderful moment in human history. For the first time we have the possibility of educating everyone on earth to each person's full potential. We have an exciting period ahead of us for world education, at all levels. Great opportunities exist for greatly improved and affordable learning based on the tutorial learning paradigm. We must be bold!

- Alfred Bork, 2001

Pask and Bork

By Shayan Doroudi