Random order set cover is as easy as offline 

Presenter: Sheng Long, Vaidehi Srinivas 

Anupam Gupta, Gregory Kehne, Roie Levin

Outline

  • Set cover, online set cover, random order online set cover
  • Unit cost, exponential time 
  • Unit cost, polynomial time 
  • Extensions and conclusions 

Set Cover

  • Ground set \(U\) and a collection of subsets \(\mathcal{S}\) 
    • \(|U|=n\), \(|\mathcal{S}|=m\)
  • Cost function: \(c:\mathcal{S}\to\mathbb{R}^+\)
  • Goal: Find \(S' \subseteq \mathcal{S}\) that covers \(U\) and has minimum cost 

Online Set Cover

  • Ground set \(U\) and a collection of subsets \(\mathcal{S}\) 
  • Cost function: \(c:\mathcal{S}\to\mathbb{R}^+\)
  • Goal: Find \(S' \subseteq \mathcal{S}\) that covers \(U\) and has minimum cost 
  • Online:
    • Elements \(v\in U\) arrive one by one;
    • When element \(v\) arrives, only knows which sets contains them and nothing else
    • Need to decide on the spot which set to pick 

could be adversarial! 

Random Order Online Set Cover

  • Ground set \(U\) and a collection of subsets \(\mathcal{S}\) 
  • Cost function: \(c:\mathcal{S}\to\mathbb{R}^+\)
  • Goal: Find \(S' \subseteq \mathcal{S}\) that covers \(U\) and has minimum cost 
  • Online:
    • Elements \(v\in U\) arrive in random order
    • When element \(v\) arrives, only knows which sets contains them and nothing else
    • Need to decide on the spot which set to pick 

LearnOrCover

  • Assume unit cost throughout 
  • Exponential time algorithm to gain intuition 
  • Polynomial time algorithm that uses potential function 

LearnOrCover (exp) 

... 

LearnOrCover (poly) 

Intuition: 

  • The function either makes progress by covering elements in the universe or by learning 
    • "learning" in the sense of multiplicative weight updating 

\(\to\) Cover

\(\to\) Learn

Define potential function \[\Phi(t):=C_1\cdot KL(x^*||x^t) + C_2 \log |U^t| \]

LearnOrCover (poly) 

  • \(O(k\cdot \log(mn))\) is achieved via the proving the following two bounds related to potential function: 
    • \(\Phi(0) = O(\log(mn))\) 
    • \(\mathbb{E}[\Delta \Phi] \leq - \frac{1}{k}\)
  • Combining the above two will give us \(\Phi(t) = O(k\log(mn))\)

\[\Phi(t):=C_1\cdot KL(x^*||x^t) + C_2 \log |U^t| \]

Random order set cover is as good as

By Sheng Long

Random order set cover is as good as

  • 21